Strategies to Reduce the Crude Protein (Nitrogen) Intake of Dairy Cows for Economic and Environmental Goals

Contents


Introduction

This fact sheet has been developed to support the implementation of the Natural Resources Conservation Service Feed Management 592 Practice Standard. The Feed Management 592 Practice Standard was adopted by NRCS in 2003 as another tool to assist with addressing resource concerns on livestock and poultry operations. Feed management can assist with reducing the import of nutrients to the farm and reduce the excretion of nutrients in manure.

Of the nitrogen (N) fed to dairy cows, only 21 to 38% actually is exported as milk or meat. That means 62 to 79% of the N fed to cows is for the most part excreted via urine and feces of cows. Most N voided in urine is quickly emitted as ammonia whereas the percent of fecal N converted to ammonia is quite variable depending upon storage management and land application method. Because most N consumed in excess of requirement is excreted in urine, to improve efficiency of N use, urinary N needs to be reduced. Changes in diet formulation can improve efficiency of N use on dairies.

Please check this link first if you are interested in organic or specialty dairy production

Definitions

N = nitrogen; CP = crude protein = N X 6.25; NPN = nonprotein N; TDN = total digestible nutrients; RDP = ruminally degraded protein; LYS = lysine; MUN = milk urea N; MCP = microbial crude protein; RUP = ruminally undegraded protein; MET = methionine; FCM = fat-corrected milk; IOFC = income over feed costs

Historical Diet Formulations For Cows

Protein nutrition of dairy cows has evolved over the decades. Initially, the approach was to determine the % or amount of dietary CP that cows needed for milk production. However, any CP consumed in excess of the cows’ requirements is excreted via urine. Thus, by feeding the cow to meet, and not exceed, her CP requirement, N excretion is reduced. The major weakness of formulating diets on a CP basis is that it ignores the type of CP consumed. For example, under this system all N in NPN sources (urea for example) is treated the same as the N in soybean meal, and clearly they are much different. The N in NPN does not include long chains of amino acids in the form of “true” protein whereas most of the N in soybean is amino-acid bound. Therefore, soybean meal contributes amino acids to both the ruminal micro-organisms and to intestinal amino acid absorption whereas NPN contributes only to the latter (Figure 1).

The goal of feeding protein to lactating cows is to support milk protein synthesis while meeting the needs for maintenance, growth and replacement of lost body protein. All proteins synthesized in the body have set amino acid patterns, so if a particular amino acid is lacking during protein synthesis, formation of that protein stops. Thus, we are not really trying to supply dietary protein to cows, we are trying to supply enough of each amino acid such that no single amino acid limits protein synthesis.

Another approach to improve upon balancing diets on a CP basis was the Burrough’s metabolizable protein system (Burroughs et al., 1975). This system considered the amount of dietary N that was solubilized in the rumen and could be used for microbial protein synthesis, a calculation that also involved the amount of TDN available to support microbial growth. To the calculated microbial protein was added the amount of dietary protein that escaped ruminal degradation. Use of ammonia and fermentable carbohydrate for microbial protein synthesis is illustrated in Figure 1. Finally, adjustment factors for digestibility and unavoidable fecal losses were applied to yield a Metabolizable Protein value. This system required knowing the amount of protein in feeds that was converted to ammonia in the rumen, the amount of feed protein that escaped ruminal breakdown, and the TDN value for the feeds. The concept was excellent but the system needed refinement.

The amount of dietary protein that is degraded in the rumen is primarily determined by characteristics of the N-containing compound (e.g., solubility and linkages) and how long it resides in the rumen (Figure 1). Residence time in the rumen, i.e. ruminal passage rate, is determined by total feed intake (the more the cow eats the faster the feed tends to move through the rumen), particle size and specific gravity (smaller, heavier particles move faster than large, light particles through the rumen), and other factors such as how quickly the microbes ferment the feed. Certain feeds are fermented faster than others (barley is fermented faster than sorghum), and feeds can be treated to reduce their rate of protein breakdown (most treatments involve lowering the protein solubility). Obviously the calculations to determine the amount of dietary protein that is degraded, or conversely undegraded, in the rumen get complicated, hence computer models tremendously speed the calculations.

Current approaches to meeting the amino acid needs of cows

First, we try to maximize microbial protein synthesis in the rumen. Microbial protein is high in LYS, and LYS is often the most limiting amino acid for milk production in feeding situations commonly found in the confined operations. Maximizing microbial protein synthesis involves supplying fermentable carbohydrates and soluble N sources to enable rapid bacterial growth. We need ammonia and other forms of soluble N to be available to the bacteria simultaneously with the fermentation of the carbohydrates so the bacteria have everything they need for growth, which includes protein synthesis (Figure 1). If the N is solubilized and degraded too quickly, much is absorbed as ammonia and subsequently excreted as urea N in urine or MUN. If too little N is solubilized in the rumen, the ammonia concentration in the ruminal fluid is too low to maximize microbial protein synthesis (Stokes et al., 1991; Clark et al., 1992). Generally, the amount of fermentable carbohydrate in the rumen is most limiting to microbial protein synthesis. Hence, the NRC (2001) predicts the yield of MCP as 0.13 x TDN (discounted), i.e., 130g MCP/kg of TDN (discounted) when RDP exceeds 1.18 x MCP yield. If the RDP intake is < 1.18 x TDN predicted MCP, then MCP is 0.85 of RDP intake. Thus, if a cow consumes 15 kg of TDN (discounted), MCP flowing to the intestine is estimated as: 15 x 0.13 = 1.95 kg.

Secondly, diets are formulated to supply amino acids for milk production by including dietary proteins that will not be completely degraded in the rumen and have a high content of the amino acids believed to be most limiting for milk production. Some feed proteins have relatively high LYS concentrations (porcine blood meal), some have relatively high MET concentrations (corn gluten meal), and some have a good balance of LYS and MET (fish meal). Thus, diets contain multiple proteins, all of which degrade at different rates in the rumen. In addition, the ruminal degradation rates for the 20 amino acids found in proteins vary substantially. Fortunately, all these data are contained in software programs so the estimated flow of feed amino acids into the small intestine is quickly calculated. Use of computer models allows us to take advantage of complementary protein and other N sources to achieve lower CP diets to achieve comparable milk yields.

Case I.

Using RDP/RUP feed data to achieve diets with a lower % CP.
Reynal and Broderick (2005) fed four diets that varied in RDP. Their diet description and results are given in Table 1. Urinary N excretion decreased about 60 g/cow/day as the % CP and % RDP decreased in the diet, however, the % milk protein also decreased. Their data suggest 11.7% RDP in ration DM as the best compromise between profitability and environmental quality.

 

Table 1. Effect of Percent Ruminal Degradable Protein on Dietary Components and Cow Responses
Dietary Treatments
A B C D
CP, % 18.8 18.3 17.7 17.2
RDP, % DM1 13.2 12.3 11.7 10.6
RDP, % of CP 70.2 67.2 66.1 61.6
RDP, % DM2 12.5 10.9 9.2 7.7
RUP, % DM1 5.8 6.2 6.0 6.6
RUP, % of CP 30.8 33.9 33.9 38.4
RUP, % DM2 6.3 7.4 8.5 9.5
NEL2, Mcal/lb DM 0.709 0.704 0.704 0.704
3.5% FCM, lb/d 93.1 94.2 93.3 91.3
Milk true protein, % 3.14a 3.14a 3.07b 3.04b
MUN, mg/dL 15.9a 15.6a 13.6b 12.8b
BUN, mg/dL 13.8a 14.0a 11.8b 12.4b
Ruminal NH3-N, mg/dL 12.33a 11.76a 8.68b 5.71c
Urinary N excretion, g/d 295a 293a 237b 239b
Fecal N excretion, g/d 222 220 219 197
N Efficiency
Milk N, % of N intake 29.6 29.5 30.4 30.4
lb of milk/lb of N excreted 84.5a 87.2a 94.3b 99.8b
1Measured in vivo.
2Predicted by NRC (2001) model.
abcMeans within the same row without a common superscript differ P < 0.05.

 

Case II.

Formulations using RUP/RDP and specific amino acids to reduce CP intake.
This concept applies RDP/RUP in predicting amino acid flows to the small intestinal tract, then adding specific amino acids to meet the cow’s requirements. The advantage is to reduce total N intake and hence, N excretion, while reducing total feed costs. Examples of using amino acid formulation to reduce CP and maintain milk yield are given below.

Example 1. VonKeyserlingk et al. (1999) formulated two diets for cows that were primarily in early lactation. The control diet was formulated according to the 1989 NRC recommendations. A second diet was formulated with the CNCPS system and included a commercial protein source and intestinally available MET source. Using a commercial protein source and “rumen by-pass” MET allowed the CP level in the grain mix to be reduced by 2.9% units and total TMR by 1% unit (Table 2).

 

Table 2. Diets formulated using NRC (1989) guidelines or CNCPS program.
Item NRC (1989) CNCPS
CP, % DM 18.7 17.7
ADF1, % DM 21.1 21.8
NEL, Mcal/lb 0.82 0.86
1Acid detergent fiber.

No difference was observed in DM intake or milk production between cows fed the diets formulated by the two methods (Table 3). The authors concluded that the CNCPS afforded the opportunity balance rations for reduced CP level without loss in milk production.

 

Table 3. Performance of dairy cows fed rations formulated by NRC (1989) guidelines or CNCPS formulation program.
Item NRC (1989) CNCPS
All cows
DMI, lb 47.4 46.6
Milk, lb 82.8 81.5
Multiparous Cows
Milk, lb 96.5 94.3
Milk fat, % 2.88 3.12
Milk protein, % 3.12 3.11
Primiparous Cows
Milk, lb 69.0 68.8
Milk fat, % 3.17 3.31
Milk protein, % 3.22 3.20

Example 2. Harrison et al. (2000) used the CPM (Cornell, Penn State, and Miner Institute) model to formulate two diets containing undegraded protein sources in the form of canola derivative or animal-marine blend. Each of these diets was estimated to be slightly deficient in LYS and MET. Two additional diets were formulated that were supplemented with a MET source and free LYS-HCl to improve the dietary supply of MET and LYS. The postpartum levels of MET and LYS in the non-supplemented diets were targeted to be at ~ 100% of the requirements (1.9% MET/MP and 6.4% LYS/MP) and 116% of MET (2.2% MET/MP) and 106% of LYS (6.6% LYS/MP) for supplemented diets. When formulating the diets, it was considered that 20 g of the commercial MET source provided 7 g of ruminal escape MET (Koenig et al.,1998) and 40 g of free LYS-HCl provided 8 g of ruminal escape LYS (Velle et al., 1998). Cows were fed the experimental diets from ~28 days before calving through week 17 postpartum. At 9 weeks post-partum, cows received rBST per label.

There tended to be increased yield of 3.5 FCM for cows fed the diet containing animal-marine bypass protein (Table 4). In early lactation, and at 14 to 17 weeks of lactation, there was an improvement in milk that appeared to be related to supplemental MET and LYS-HCl. In the early weeks of lactation (weeks 1 to 4) the MET supplemented cows fed the animal-marine blend protein source diet produced the most milk. After the beginning of rBST use (week 5), cows fed both un-supplemented diets (canola derivative and the animal-marine blend) produced more milk when supplemented with MET and LYS-HCl. A trend (P<0.14) was observed for increased milk fat percentage when the diets were supplemented with MET and LYS-HCl. These observations support the use of supplemental MET and LYS particularly during the critical need periods of early lactation and post rBST administration.

 

Table 4. Performance of cows fed diets containing supplemental sources of rumen undegraded amino acids.
P <
Item Treated canola protein Treated canola protein + Lys & Met Animal-marine blend protein Animal-marine blend protein + Lys & Met Pro-
tein
Suppl-
ement
Pro-
tein x Suppl
DMI, lb 48.2 48.0 48.8 47.7 NS NS NS
Milk, lb 85.4 85.6 87.1 87.3 NS NS NS
3.5 FCM, lb 86.9 87.6 89.3 91.1 0.08 NS NS
Milk fat, lb 3.08 3.12 3.19 3.28 0.03 NS NS
Milk fat, % 3.65 3.71 3.68 3.80 NS 0.14 NS
Milk protein, % 3.09 3.13 3.12 3.36 NS NS NS
Milk protein, lb 2.62 2.62 2.68 2.86 0.22 NS NS

Case III.

The importance of formulating for desired ratios of MET to LYS.
In another study (Harrison et al., 2003), researchers employed the CPM formulation model to reduce dietary CP from 18% to 16% by replacing alfalfa silage with corn silage and undegraded protein sources (Tables 5 & 6). Diet #3 was predicted to have the best ratio and supply of MET and LYS, and resulted in the highest milk yield, and ratio of milk true protein to diet protein (Table 7). The reduced milk yield of cows fed diet #2 emphasizes the need to ensure the ratio of LYS to MET is ~ 3.2 to 1. Total N import (as feed N) onto the dairy was reduced by nearly 9% and IOFC was increased 6.5% by diet #3.

 

Table 5. Chemical Analysis of Total Mixed Rations (% DM).
Item Diet 1 Diet 2 Diet 3 SE
CP 18.6 16.0 16.0 0.35
NDF1 38.9 41.2 44.7 1.88
Soluble CP 7.53 5.1 5.4 0.38
Soluble CP, % of CP 40.5 31.9 33.8
NFC2 31.9 34.4 30.7 2.16
1Neutral detergent fiber
2Nonfiber carbohydrate

 

Table 6. Diet Formulation Results from CPM
Item Diet 1 Diet 2 Diet 3
Lysine, % required 89 99 116
Methionine, % required 91 116 109
Ratio of Lys/Met 3.32 2.89 3.16
MP1 balance, g -477 -104 -117
1Metabolizable protein

 

Table 7. Response of cows to diets that differ in crude protein and ratio of lysine to methionine
Item Diet 1 Diet 2 Diet 3 SE P <
DMI, lb 44.9 45.1 45.1 2.97 NS
Milk, lb 78.8 77.9 82.5 5.10 NS
Milk Fat, % 3.80a 3.24b 3.79a 0.151 0.01
Milk Protein, % 3.08 3.08 3.07 0.071 NS
MUN, mg/dL 18.8a 13.0b 14.4b 0.92 0.01
CP Intake, lb/d 8.34 7.22 7.22
Milk True Protein/Feed CP 0.29 0.33 0.34
Reduction in CP imports, % — 8.6 8.6
IOFC1, $/d/cow 5.49 4.64 5.85
1Income over feed costs

 

Case IV.

Impact of reduced dietary % CP on N excretion on a commercial dairy. A field study (Harrison et al., 2002) was conducted with a high producing herd to compare the general herd diet formulated at ~18% CP to a diet that was reformulated at ~17% (Table 8). Milk production was maintained while N imports to the farm (Tables 9 & 10) were decreased. In addition, the reformulated diet increased IOFC (Table 11). These results agree with those of Wattiaux and Karg (2004) who reported a 16% drop in urinary N when a diet with 18% CP was reformulated to 16.5% CP.

 

Table 8. Chemical compositions of a control diet and a reformulated diet containing supplemental amino acids.
Item Control Reformulated
CP, % DM 17.8 17.0
Soluble Protein, % DM 6.4 6.0
Soluble Protein, % CP 35.7 37.0
NDF<suo>1</sup>, % DM 32.4 32.7
NFC2, % DM 39.0 39.8
1Neutral detergent fiber
2Nonfiber carbohydrate

 

Table 9. Treatment response to a diet reformulated on the basis of metabolizable methionine and lysine.
Item Control Reformulated SE P <
DMI, lb 56.7 55.2
CP Intake, lb 10.1 9.4
Milk, lb 99.9 101.9 0.53 0.007
3.5 FCM, lb 96.0 96.6 0.46 0.32
Milk fat, % 3.28 3.21 0.014 0.001
Milk protein, % 2.90 2.93 0.006 0.0009
MUN, mg/dL 17.5 14.5
Milk True Protein: Intake Protein Ratio 0.285 0.316

 

Table 10. Effect on nitrogen excretion when a diet was reformulated on the basis of metabolizable lysine and methionine
Item Control Reformulated % Change
N intake, g/d 734 680 -7.4
Milk total N, g/d1 240 246 +2.5
Predicted Urinary N, g/d2 289 239 -17.3
Calculated Fecal N, g/d3 205 195 -5.0
1(Milk True Protein/6.38) X 1.17
2Urinary N (g/d) = 0.026 x BW (kg) X MUN (mg/dL); J Dairy Sci. 85:227-233.
3Fecal N = Intake N – Milk N – Urine N

 

Table 11. Economic impact of reformulating a diet on the basis of metabolizable lysine and methionine
Item Control Reformulated
Feed Costs, $/d/cow 4.82 4.88
Milk Income, $/d/cow 11.92 12.10
IOFC1, $/d/cow 7.10 7.22
1IOFC = Income over feed costs

 

Summary

Reducing CP intake of high-producing cows can be achieved by strategic use of undegraded protein sources and amino acids (LYS and MET) under a variety of diet conditions. Diet reformulations can reduce N excretions by ~10% without negatively affecting milk yield or IOFC. These successes require the use of ration balancing software that estimate the amino acid (MET and LYS especially) needs of the lactating cow. Use of undegraded protein sources that have dependable concentrations of amino acids is critical to achieve consistent production responses.

 

RUP Fig 1.jpg

 

 

Selected References

Burroughs, W., D.K. Nelson, and D.R. Mertens. 1975. Evaluation of protein nutrition by metabolizable protein and urea fermentation potential. J. Dairy Sci. 58:611-619.

Clark, J.H., T.H. Klusmeyer, and M.R. Cameron. 1992. Symposium: Nitrogen metabolism and amino acid nutrition in dairy cattle: Microbial protein synthesis and flows of nitrogen fractions to the duodenum of dairy cows. J. Dairy Sci. 75:2304-2323.

Harrison, J.H., D. Davidson, L. Johnson, M.L. Swift, M. VonKeyserlingk, M. Vazquez-Anon, and W. Chalupa. 2000. Effect of source of bypass protein and supplemental Alimet and lysine-HCl on lactation performance. J. Dairy Sci. 83(suppl 1):268.

Harrison, J.H., D. Davidson, J. Werkhoven, A. Werkhoven, S. Werkhoven, M. Vazquez-Anon, G. Winter, N. Barney, and W. Chalupa. 2002. Effectiveness of strategic ration balancing on efficiency of milk protein production and environmental impact. J. Dairy Sci. 85(suppl.1):205.

Harrison, J.H., R.L. Kincaid, W. Schager, L. Johnson, D. Davidson, L.D. Bunting, and W. Chalupa. 2003. Strategic ration balancing by supplementing lysine, methionine, and Prolak on efficiency of milk protein production and potential environmental impact. J. Dairy Sci. 86(Suppl 1):60.

Koenig, K.M., L.M. Rode, C.D. Knight, and P.R. McCullough. 1999. Ruminal escape, gastrointestinal absorption, and response of serum methionine to supplementation of liquid methionine hydroxyl analog in dairy cows. J. Dairy Sci. 82:355.

NRC. 1989. National Research Council. Nutrient Requirements of Dairy Cattle. Vol. 6th rev. ed. Natl. Acad. Sci., Washington, DC.

NRC. 2001. National Research Council. Nutrient Requirements of Dairy Cattle. Vol. 7th rev. ed. Natl. Acad. Sci., Washington, DC.

Reynal, S.M. and G.A. Broderick. 2005. Effect of dietary level of rumen-degraded protein on production and nitrogen metabolism in lactating dairy cows. J. Dairy Sci. 88:4045-4064.

Stokes, S.R., W.H. Hoover, T.K. Miller, and R. Blauweikel. 1991. Ruminal digestion and microbial utilization of diets varying in type of carbohydrate and protein. J. Dairy Sci. 74:871-881.

Tamminga, S. 1992. Nutrition management of dairy cows as a contribution to pollution control. J. Dairy Sci. 75:345-357.

Velle W., T.I. Kanui, A. Aulie, and O.C. Sjaastad. 1998. Ruminal escape and apparent degradation of amino acids administered intraruminally in mixtures to cows. J. Dairy Sci. 81:3231-3238.

VonKeyserlingk, M.A.G., M.L. Swift, and J.A. Shelford. 1999. Use of the Cornell Net Carbohydrate and Protein System and rumen-protected methionine to maintain milk production in cows receiving reduced protein diets. Can. J. Anim. Sci. 79:397-400.

Wattiaux, M. A. 1998. Protein metabolism in dairy cows. In: Technical Dairy Guide—Nutrition, 2nd edition. The Babcock Institute for International Dairy Research and Development. The University of Wisconsin.

Wattiaux, M.A and K.L. Karg. 2004. Protein level for alfalfa and corn silage-based diets: II. Nitrogen balance and manure characteristics. J. Dairy Sci. 87:3492-3502.

“Extension programs and policies are consistent with federal and state laws and regulations on nondiscrimination regarding race, sex, religion, age, color, creed, national or ethnic origin; physical, mental or sensory disability; marital status, sexual orientation, or status as a Vietnam-era or disabled veteran. Evidence of noncompliance may be reported through your local Extension office.”

 

Disclaimer

This fact sheet reflects the best available information on the topic as of the publication date. Date 6-20-2006

This Feed Management Education Project was funded by the USDA NRCS CIG program. Additional information can be found at Feed Management Publications.

Image:Feed mgt logo4.JPG

This project is affiliated with the Livestock and Poultry Environmental Learning Center.

Image:usda,nrcs,feed_mgt_logo.JPG

Project Information

Detailed information about training and certification in Feed Management can be obtained from Joe Harrison, Project Leader, jhharrison@wsu.edu, or Becca White, Project Manager, rawhite@wsu.edu.

Author Information

R. L. Kincaid rkincaid@wsu.edu
J. H. Harrison
R. A. White
Washington State University

Reviewer Information

Floyd Hoisington – Consulting Nutritionist

Michael Wattiaux – University of Wisconsin

Partners

Image:Logos2.JPG

Grouping Dairy Cows

Introduction

This fact sheet has been developed to support the implementation of the Natural Resources Conservation Service Feed Management 592 Practice Standard. The Feed Management 592 Practice Standard was adopted by NRCS in 2003 as another tool to assist with addressing resource concerns on livestock and poultry operations. Feed management can assist with reducing the import of nutrients to the farm and reduce the excretion of nutrients in manure.

The trend over the past 15 years has been to feed a single total mixed ration to the dairy herd. Higher producing cows have a greater dry matter intake and, therefore, receive more nutrients daily. Unfortunately, most feeding systems consequently over-feed lower producers to assure that higher producers receive enough feed of the correct concentration of nutrients. Feeds are usually inexpensive compared to the return generated by milk sales, and the results of this feeding practice were higher production at a moderate cost.

Surveys of milk production versus nutrient consumption done regionally around the United States have shown significant over-feeding of protein and phosphorus on dairy farms. In some cases, rations provided as much as 50% more phosphorus than needed for the herd’s production level. Certainly, these high levels can be reduced through the choice of feed ingredients and more precise mineral feeding, however producers want assurance their cows have adequate nutrients for optimum milk production. There is a middle ground where producers can feed for optimum performance while meeting the demands of changing environmental constraints.

Dividing the herd into two or three feeding groups allows tailoring rations more closely to the production level and nutrient requirements of the group. By feeding more cows more closely to their requirements, a producer can reduce waste and the excretion of excess nitrogen and phosphorus.

Please check this link first if you are interested in organic or specialty dairy production

The Basics of Grouping Cows

Obviously, a dairy farm must have facilities so cows can be divided into multiple groups. The size of the groups are influenced by the size of the milking parlor, the barns or corrals available for housing the cows, other grouping currently done (dry cows, heifers), and the ability to deliver different rations to different groups of cows. Furthermore, the average age of the herd, average days in milk, and reproductive goals (AI, bull bred, etc.) are all factors that must be considered.

There are many schemes for deciding which cows to group together. Some producers group cows by days in milk or where they are in the production curve. This method is roughly equal to grouping by daily milk production, but some cows produce twice as much daily milk as other cows at the same point in the lactation cycle. Other farms group according to the cows’ reproductive status. Higher producing, early lactation cows are usually not bred so putting them together in a group allows feeding for the higher production and for more efficient heat detection and artificial insemination. However, not all early lactation cows produce at the same level. The most successful way to group cows has been shown to be selecting cows based on the nutrients required per pound of feed; for example nutrients such as crude protein, starch, sugar, fiber, fat, vitamins, and minerals. While directly related to daily milk production, it is a more precise way to feed cows what they need without waste and over-excretion of nutrients (Williams, 1992).

It appears that feeding in three groups produces higher income over feed costs than feeding two groups and group feeding in two groups results are better than one group feeding (Williams, 2002). A California survey showed feeding three groups reduced nitrogen excretion by 15% over herds feeding a one-group TMR (Castillo, 2000).

Why not then?

There are some important considerations when grouping cows for more efficient use of feed nutrients. It takes professional help to formulate rations for and to monitor the performance of different production groups. A nutritionist can also help monitor the quality of feed ingredients used in rations.

All feeds vary in nutrient content load to load and throughout storage. Table 1 shows the mean content of protein and net energy-lactation of common feeds in the northeastern U.S. It also shows the standard deviation derived from the group of feed samples. Adding and subtracting the standard deviation from the mean shows the range in nutrient content for two-thirds of the samples. The other third of the samples tested outside of this range. For example, the mean corn silage contained 7.9% crude protein, and had a standard deviation of 1.3%. This means that two-thirds of the samples tested between 6.6% and 9.2% CP, so one-third tested either greater or less than that range. A ration formulated to supply 6.1 pounds of protein to support the average milk production of the group could be as low as 5.5 pounds and this would result in a loss of almost 7 pounds of milk per day.

Table 1. Mean composition and standard deviation of Crude Protein and Net Energy Lactation of some feedstuffs used in the northeastern US.
  Crude Protein % NEL (Mcal/kg)
Ingredients Mean S.D. Mean S.D.
  ———-% of dry matter———-
Mixed hay 15.9 2.9 1.25 0.18
Mixed haylage 15.6 3.2 1.15 0.20
Corn silage 7.9 1.3 1.50 0.15
Ground ear corn 9.4 1.6 1.85 0.07
  ————% as fed————-
Brewers dried grains 25.4 2.0 1.47 0.07
Corn gluten feed 20.9 1.3 1.72 0.08
Corn gluten meal 63.5 4.1 1.81 0.09
Corn grain 9.1 0.5 1.78 0.04
Distillers dried grains 27.5 2.5 1.86 0.11
Feather meal 85.3 1.8 1.48 0.02
Meat and bone meal 50.8 2.9 1.51 0.09
Molasses 3.2 0.3 1.23 0.02
Soybean meal (Solvent) 49.5 1.2 1.81 0.05
Wheat Grain 15.3 0.9 1.81 0.04

How can the risk of nutrient variation be controlled? Nutrients can be over-fed, but that defeats the point of grouping for more efficiency and results in more nutrients excreted. Formulating rations with multiple sources of protein and energy can reduce the risk because it is unlikely that all sources would vary on the low side at one time. Blending single commodities can help as well. One truck load of corn taken from storage containing multiple loads of corn will vary less than a single source. (St. Pierre, 1999). Therefore, receiving larger quantities (train car load vs. truck load) of a single ingredient is best if inventory control, purchasing, and transportation will allow.

Testing all feeds is important in managing the variation of feedstuffs. Notice that forages vary the most so they must be monitored closely. Experienced managers and researchers suggest the following testing schedule (St. Pierre, 1999):

All feeds – Protein, fat, fiber, minerals at purchase or harvest
Forages – weekly for moisture, monthly for protein, fiber (more often if fed quickly)
TMRs – monthly for particle size before and after eating
All feeds – four times a year for macrominerals
Silages – twice a year for VFAs and pH

One obvious way to control variation in the quality of feedstuffs is to reduce or eliminate the use of the feeds most prone to large variations.

Group Feeding Strategies

When feeding groups of cows, nutrients are provided to the average daily production of the group. The average cow in each of three groups is closer in production to her group-mates than the average cow is to the entire herd. However, by feeding the average cow in the group, rations will be inadequate for the higher producing cows in the group. Higher dry matter intake will make up for some of the shortage, but most managers will “lead feed” the group to supply necessary nutrients to the top half of the group. Lead feeding factors have been developed through trial and error and by research using commercial dairy herds. One rule of thumb to lead feeding was to feed the average cow plus one standard deviation of the variation in the group. If the average for a group is 70 pounds/cow-day and the standard deviation in the group is 5 pounds; the herd would be fed for 75 pounds per day. This works when production variation is small due to many production groups. When feeding two or three groups, researchers in Virginia and Ohio have developed lead factors as shown in Table 2.

Table 2. Optimum ration lead factors for energy and protein proposed by The Ohio State University and those proposed by McGilliard et al. at V. P. I.
    Lead factors
Number of Groups Group # NE1% CP% V. P. I.%
1 Group   133 126 132
2 Groups 1 Highs 119 113 117
2 Lows 130 125 123
3 Groups 1 Top 115 111 114
2 Middle 121 117 110
3 Lows 129 124 121

Notice two things: 1.) Lead factors are different for protein and energy in the Ohio work, 2.) The level of lead feeding over the entire herd can be reduced when feeding more production groups. In a three group dairy, the top string would be fed 115% of the average nutrient requirement based on energy in the Ohio system or 114% of average in the VPI system.

In summary, grouping cows can be part of a total feed management program to reduce waste and the excretion of unused nutrients. Grouping cows by production level or stage of lactation is most common. In addition, grouping cows is beneficial for dairy producers because it helps control feed costs. It promotes feeding valuable nutrients to benefit cows at different stages of lactation and results in optimum efficiency, productivity, and profitability.

References

Castillo A.R., E. Kebreab , D.E.Beever and J. France. 2000. A review of efficiency of nitrogen utilization in dairy cows and its relationship with the environmental pollution. J. Anim. and Feed Sci. 9:1-32.

Castillo. A.R., E. Kebreab, D.E. Beever, J.H. Barbi, J.D. Sutton, H.C. Kirby and J. France. 2001. The effect of protein supplementation on nitrogen utilization in lactating dairy cows fed grass silage diets. J. Anim. Sci. 79:247-253.

Dou, Z., R.A. Kohn, J.D. Ferguson, R.C. Boston, and J.D. Newbold. 1996.Managing nitrogen on dairy farms: an integrated approach I. Model description. J. Dairy Sci. 79:2071-2080.

Grant, R.J. and J.L. Albright. 2001. Effect of Animal Grouping on Feeding Behavior and Intake of Dairy Cattle. J. Dairy Sci. 84(E.Suppl.):E156-E163. McGilliard, M.L, J.M. Swisher, and R.E. James. 1983. Grouping lactating cows by nutritional requirements for feeding. J.Dairy Sci. 66:1084-1093.

Sniffen C.J., R.W. Beverly, C.S. Mooney, M.B. Roe and A.L. Skidmore. 1993. Nutrient requirement versus supplied in the dairy cow: strategies to account for variability. J. Dairy Sci. 76:3160-3169.

Sniffen C.J. 1991. Grouping management and physical facilities. Vet. Clin. North Am. Small Anim. Pract. 7:465-478.

St-Pierre, N.R. and C.S. Thraen. 1999. Animal Grouping Strategies, Sources of Variation, and Economic Factors Affecting Nutrient Balance on Dairy Farms. J. Dairy Sci. 82 (Suppl. 2):72-83.

Williams, C.B. and P.A. Oltenacu. 1992. Evaluation of Criteria Used to Group Lactating Cows Using a Dairy Production Model. J.Dairy Sci. 75:155-160.

“Extension programs and policies are consistent with federal and state laws and regulations on nondiscrimination regarding race, sex, religion, age, color, creed, national or ethnic origin; physical, mental or sensory disability; marital status, sexual orientation, or status as a Vietnam-era or disabled veteran. Evidence of noncompliance may be reported through your local Extension office.”

 

Disclaimer

This fact sheet reflects the best available information on the topic as of the publication date. Date 6-20-2006

This Feed Management Education Project was funded by the USDA NRCS CIG program. Additional information can be found at Feed Management Publications.

Image:Feed mgt logo4.JPG

This project is affiliated with the LPELC.

Image:usda,nrcs,feed_mgt_logo.JPG

Project Information

Detailed information about training and certification in Feed Management can be obtained from Joe Harrison, Project Leader, jhharrison@wsu.edu, or Becca White, Project Manager, rawhite@wsu.edu.

Author Information

Mike Gamroth
Extension Dairy Specialist
Oregon State University

Reviewer Information

Tamilee Nennich – Texas A & M

Vince Waters – Consulting Nutritionist

Partners

Image:Logos2.JPG

 

An Introduction to Natural Resources Conservation Service (NRCS) Feed Management Practice Standard 592

Printer friendly version

Introduction

This factsheet has been developed to support the implementation of the Natural Resources Conservation Service (NRCS) Feed Management 592 Practice Standard. The Feed Management 592 Practice Standard was adopted by NRCS in 2003 as another tool to assist with addressing resource concerns on livestock and poultry operations. Feed management can assist with reducing the import of nutrients to the farm and reduce the excretion of nutrients in manure.

Please check this link first if you are interested in organic or specialty dairy production

Why Is Feed Management Important?

Feed represents the largest import of nutrients to the farm, followed by commercial fertilizer CAST Issue Paper # 21 – Animal Diet Modification to Decrease the Potential for Nitrogen and Phosphorus Pollution. Feed management practices impact the amount of nutrients that are imported to the farm and excreted in manure. The excreted nutrients are subsequently available for volatile loss (nitrogen) to the atmosphere and are potentially lost via surface runoff (nitrogen and phosphorus) or leached to groundwater (nitrogen and phosphorus).

Feed management opportunities currently exist to reduce imports of nutrients (particularly nitrogen and phosphorus) to most animal livestock and poultry operations. Because consulting nutritionists play such a key role with regard to importation of nutrients to the farm, a systematic approach to evaluate the role that feed management has on whole-farm nutrient management is warranted.

What Is the NRCS Standard 592?

The NRCS Feed Management Practice Standard is defined as “managing the quantity of available nutrients fed to livestock and poultry for their intended purpose.” The purposes of the 592 standard are:

  • To supply the quantity of available nutrients required by livestock and poultry for maintenance, production, performance, and reproduction, while reducing the quantity of nutrients, especially nitrogen and phosphorus, excreted in manure by minimizing the overfeeding of these and other nutrients
  • To improve net farm income by feeding nutrients more efficiently

The ultimate goal of utilizing the Feed Management Practice Standard 592 is to develop a farm-specific Feed Management Plan, or FMP. A five-step process has been adopted for the development and implementation of a FMP.

Implementing a FMP as outlined in NRCS Feed Management Practice Standard 592 can be expected to have the following environmental benefits:

  1. Reduce on-farm import of nutrients
  2. Reduce nutrients in manure for subsequent land application and potential loss to ground and surface water
  3. Reduce nutrients in manure and subsequent volatile losses
Feed mgmt flow.jpg


A complete copy of the national version of NRCS Feed Management 592 Practice Standard can be found at the end of this publication. Please check your state-specific version of the standard.

 

Ten Reasons to Implement a Systematic Approach to Feed Management

There are a number of reasons for consulting nutritionists and ARPAS members to consider the adoption of a systematic approach to feed management. Following are our Top 10:

  1. Society demands animal agriculture to be environmentally responsible.
  2. Many farms are in a positive import-export balance for nitrogen and phosphorus, even when losses of nitrogen are considered.
  3. Feed is the primary import of nutrients on most livestock and poultry farms.
  4. Adopting feed management practices is proactive toward becoming sustainable.
  5. Feed management is an additional practice that can assist in the mitigation of nutrient buildup.
  6. There is an ethical obligation for nutritionists to consider a systematic feed management program to reduce import of nutrients to the farm.
  7. Agriculture should get credit for practices already implemented. Adoption of NRCS feed management is an option, not mandated.
  8. Adopting Feed Management 592 can likely increase profitability.
  9. Adopting Feed Management 592 can result in incentive payments to the producer and consultant.
  10. Adopting Feed Management 592 provides a nutritionist the opportunity to increase his or her suite of services to producers.

 

Text of the 592 Standard

Natural Resources Conservation Service Conservation Practice Standard
Feed Management
(No. of Systems and AUs Affected)
CODE 592

Definition

Managing the quantity of available nutrients fed to livestock and poultry for their intended purpose.

Purpose

  • To supply the quantity of available nutrients required by livestock and poultry for maintenance, production, performance, and reproduction, while reducing the quantity of nutrients, especially nitrogen and phosphorus, excreted in manure by minimizing the over-feeding of these and other nutrients
  • To improve net farm income by feeding nutrients more efficiently

Conditions Where Practice Applies

  • Confined livestock and poultry operations with a whole-farm nutrient imbalance, with more nutrients imported to the farm than are exported and/or utilized by cropping programs
  • Confined livestock and poultry operations that have a significant buildup of nutrients in the soil due to land application of manure
  • Confined livestock and poultry operations that land apply manure and do not have a land base large enough to allow nutrients to be applied at rates recommended by soil test and utilized by crops in the rotation
  • Livestock and poultry operations seeking to enhance nutrient efficiencies

Criteria

General Criteria Applicable to All Purposes

The diets for specific species of animals shall be developed in accordance with recommendations from one of the following:

  • Standards outlined in the most current recommendations of the National Research Council (NRC).
  • Recommendations of the land-grant university.
  • Standards developed by the professional nutritionists of livestock and poultry production companies, feed companies, and/or feed suppliers. Laboratory analysis shall be done on the formulated diet or on the feed ingredients used to formulate the diet, to determine its nutrient content.
  • Feed analyses by laboratories whose tests are accepted by the land-grant university in the state in which the feeding strategy will be implemented. Data from analyzed feed ingredients and/or appropriate historic feed analysis. information for the operation will be used for adjustments of ration formulation.
  • Diets and feed management strategies developed by professional animal scientists, independent professional nutritionists, or other comparably qualified individuals. When required by state policy or regulation, animal nutritionists shall be certified through any certification program recognized within the state.
  • Diets shall be formulated to provide the quantities and correct relative ratios of available nutrients required by the animal species to meet species goals for which the plan is being developed.
  • Adjustments to nutrient levels shall be provided to meet specific genetic potential, environmental demands, and/or requirements to insure health, well-being and productivity.

One or more of the following feed management practices and/or diet manipulation technologies shall be used to reduce nitrogen, phosphorus, and other excreted nutrients while maintaining the health, well-being and productivity of the animal:

  • Formulating diets closer to animal requirements
  • Reducing protein and supplementing with amino acids (nonruminants)
  • Manipulating the crude protein and energy (carbohydrate and fat) content of the diet to enhance the availability of amino acids (ruminants)
  • Using highly digestible feeds, as appropriate, in the diet
  • Using phytase and reducing the supplemental phosphorus content of the diet (nonruminants)
  • Reducing the phosphorus content of the diet of ruminants when it is being overfed
  • Using selected enzymes or other products to enhance feed digestibility or feed use efficiency
  • Using growth promotants as allowed by law
  • Implementing phase feeding
  • Implementing split-sex feeding
  • Using other feed management or diet manipulation technologies that have demonstrated the ability to reduce manure nutrient content

When analysis of manure is done to determine manure nutrient content, the analysis shall be performed by laboratories whose results are accepted by the land-grant university in the state in which the feeding strategy was implemented.

Considerations

Consider nutrient requirements for production based upon stage of growth, intended purpose of the animal, and the type of production (e.g., meat, milk, eggs) involved.

  • Use management practices described in the NRCS Nutrient Management (Feed Management) Technical Notes for the specific animal species.
  • Analyze the drinking water consumed by the animals to determine its nutrient content, and adjusting the diet to account for this source of nutrients.
  • Different feed ingredients (e.g. by- products) and their potential impacts on the nutrient content of excreted manure.
  • The potential impact of feed management on the volume of manure excreted and on manure storage requirements.
  • The impact of feed management practices, animal management practices, and diet manipulation on manure odors, pathogens, animal health and well-being.
  • Using concentrates and forages grown on the farm to minimize the quantity of nutrients imported to the farm, and to maximize the recycling of nutrients on the farm.
  • Analyzing excreted manure or manure from storage facilities to determine manure nutrient content and to estimate the impact of the feeding strategy.

Plans and Specifications

Plans and specifications for feed management shall be in keeping with the requirements of this standard. They shall describe the specific feed management practices and/or technologies that are planned for the operation. The following components shall be included in the feed management plan:

  • The type of technology, or technologies, and/or feeding practices that will be used on the operation
  • Feed analyses and ration formulation information prior to and after implementation of feed management on the operation
  • The estimated, or measured, nutrient content of the manure prior to the implementation of feed management on the operation
  • The estimated impact that feed management will have on manure nutrient content
  • Guidance for how often the feed management plan shall be reviewed and potentially revised
  • The quantities and sources of nitrogen and phosphorus that will be fed
  • Identification of the qualified feed management specialist who developed the plan.

Operation and Maintenance

The producer/client is responsible for the operation and maintenance of the feed management plan. Operation and maintenance activities address the following:

  • Periodic plan review to determine if adjustments or modifications are needed
  • Routine feed analysis to document the rates at which nitrogen and phosphorus were actually fed; when actual rates fed differ from or exceed the planned rates, records will indicate the reasons for the differences.
  • Maintaining records to document plan implementation. As applicable, records include:
    • Records of feed analysis and ration formulation, including the record of ration formulation used prior to implementing the feeding strategy
    • Records of the initial estimate of the impact the feeding strategy was expected to have on reducing manure nutrient content
    • Records of any manure analysis that was done after the feeding strategy was implemented to determine manure nutrient content
    • Dates of review and person performing the review and any recommendations that resulted from the review.

Records of plan implementation shall be maintained for five year, or for a period longer than five years if required by other federal, state, or local ordinances, program, or contract requirements.

 

Disclaimer

This factsheet reflects the best available information on the topic as of the publication date. Date 4-12-2007

This Feed Management Education Project was funded by the USDA NRCS CIG program. Additional information can be found at Feed Management Publications. Image:Feed mgt logo4.JPG

This project is affiliated with the Livestock and Poultry Environmental Learning Center.

Image:usda,nrcs,feed_mgt_logo.JPG

Project Information

Detailed information about training and certification in feed management can be obtained from Joe Harrison, project leader, jhharrison@wsu.edu, or Becca White, project manager, rawhite@wsu.edu.

Author Information

J. H. Harrison, Washington State University, jhharrison@wsu.edu
R. A. White, Washington State University
A. Sutton and Todd Applegate, Purdue University
Galen Erickson, University of Nebraska
R. Burns, Iowa State University

Partners

Logos2.JPG


 

Acknowledgements

This Feed Management Education Project was funded by the USDA NRCS CIG program. Additional information can be found at Feed Management Publications.
This project is affiliated with the Livestock and Poultry Environmental Learning Center

usda,nrcs,feed_mgt_logo.JPG


 

“Extension programs and policies are consistent with federal and state laws and regulations on nondiscrimination regarding race, sex, religion, age, color, creed, national or ethnic origin; physical, mental or sensory disability; marital status, sexual orientation, or status as a Vietnam-era or disabled veteran. Evidence of noncompliance may be reported through your local Extension office.”

 

Direct Fed Microbial Products (DFM)

Printer friendly version

Introduction

This fact sheet has been developed to support the implementation of the Natural Resources Conservation Service Feed Management 592 Practice Standard. The Feed Management 592 Practice Standard was adopted by NRCS in 2003 as another tool to assist with addressing resource concerns on livestock and poultry operations. Feed management can assist with reducing the import of nutrients to the farm and reduce the excretion of nutrients in manure.

The concept of Direct Fed Microbial (DFM) involves the feeding of beneficial microbes to dairy cattle when they are under periods of stress (disease, ration changes, environmental, or production challenges). Probiotics is another term for this category of feed additives. Probiotics or DFM have been shown to improve animal performance in controlled studies. In this section, we will evaluate bacterial additives (not fungal or yeast-based products).

Please check this link first if you are interested in organic or specialty dairy production

Role of Direct Fed Microbials

The proposed mechanisms for improvement in dairy cattle performance when feeding DFM are outlined below.

  • Produce of anti-bacterial compounds (acids, bacteriocins, or antibiotics)
  • Compete against undesirable (pathogenic) organisms for nutrients and/or colonization of the digestive tract (competitive exclusion)
  • Produce nutrients or other growth factors
  • Stimulate production of enzymes and/or stimulate growth of natural bacteria
  • Metabolize or detoxify undesirable compounds (such lactic acid, mycotoxins, etc.)
  • Stimulate the immune system

Several studies the have reported positive animal performance when using a combination of several microbial species listed in Table 1.

The mode action and dosages of many bacterial species are given in Table 2. For example, Lactobacillus acidophilis produces lactic acid that may lower the pH in the small intestine thereby inhibiting the growth of undesirable microbes (pathogens). Calves that have been stressed (i.e. weaning, scouring, and shipping challenges) have responded quite favorability to large doses of Bifidobacterium, Enterococcus, Bacillus, and Lactobacillus. Megasphaera elsdenii is a major lactate utilizing organism found in the rumen of cattle fed high grain diets. Feedlot producers have used DFM when adapting cattle to high energy diets thereby reducing lactic acidosis. Applications in high producing cows are being explored in the field. Propionibacteria have the ability to convert lactic acid and glucose to acetic and propionic acid thereby potentially improving the energy status of early lactation cows. Similar results have been demonstrated in beef cattle through improved feed efficiency. Certain species of bacteria can reduce/detoxify nitrates in the ration.

Practical Considerations

The bacteria in DFM products must be alive to impact ruminal fermentation or lower gut responses. Thus, the viability and number of organisms fed must be ensured at the time of feeding to ensure performance responses. The use of DNA figure printing offers an approach to select the optimal strain(s) of bacteria to ensure optimal animal performance. Some products have guaranteed levels (i.e. 1 x 106 – 10 CFU/g) of micro-organisms in the product to achieve animal performance.

The method of delivery of these products can vary from powders, pastes, boluses, to capsules using feed or water as carriers. If water is used, chlorination, temperature, minerals, flow rates, ionophores, and antibiotics must be considered to avoid killing or reducing the effectiveness of the DFM product. For example, the approval of monensin, which targets gram positive bacteria in the rumen, may result in certain DFM products being less effective due to the microbials being affected by monensin. Producers and nutritionists need to ask for controlled studies demonstrating the use of a particular DFM product in combination with monensin. Some DFM products may require a higher feeding rate or dosage to “seed down” the digestive tract for several days to out compete pathogenic bacteria followed by reducing the feeding rate to achieve a maintenance rate.

The ability of DFM to survive feed processing, especially pelleting, should be requested for each product. In addition, viability data during prolonged feed storage and stability when mixed with low pH silages in the bunk for several hours should be requested. The viability of DFM products in the market place has improved over the years, but follow manufacturers directions concerning heat, oxygen exposure, and moisture to ensure product performance and ultimately animal performance.

Summary

At this time, most nutritionists are “cautious” when adding DFM. However, the success in controlled and field studies has demonstrated improvements in animal performance. The use of DFM’s in milk fed calves seems to warrant the inclusion of a DFM product until dry matter intake of starter is over two pounds per calf per day. The inclusion of DFM products in drench products administered to off-feed cows, cows treated with high levels of antibiotics for various diseases, and those cows under stress would appear to be warranted. At this point, ask for data on animal performance responses to DFM products, evaluate the type and number of microbes added, and follow handling guidelines to ensure product performance and ultimately animal performance.

Table 1. Effects of bacterial DFM on dry matter intake, milk yield, and milk composition in lactating dairy cows in five studies (Krehbiel et al.).
Treatment number Milk (lb/day) Fat (%) Protein (%) DMI (lb)
Control
L. acidophilis (BT1386)
16
16
64.0a
68.0b
3.81
3.75
3.34
3.36
na
na
Control
L. acidophilis (BT1386)
550
550
70.0a
73.9b
3.64
3.63
na
na
46.6
47.1
Control**
Yeast culture
L. acidophilis + yeast culture
6
6
6
18.0a
20.5b
20.4b
3.30a
3.96b
3.57b
3.09
3.15
3.13
na
na
na
Control
Yeast + L. plantarum and E. faecium
32
32
106.0
108.0
na
na
3.01a
3.27b
54.1
55.2
Control
L. acidophilis, L. casei, E. faecium + Mannanoligosaccharide
100
100
85.4
87.1
4.24
4.34
3.02
3.04
55.0
54.1
abMeans in columns differ (P < 0.05)
**Tropical feeding conditions

 

Table 2. Bacteria with potential use as DFM (Kung, 2001).
Source Strain Dose Effect
Megashrera
elsdenii
B1459
407A
8.7 x 106 Prevent lactic acidosis when diets change to higher fermented CHO
Lactobacillus
acidophilis
na 1 x 109 Increase milk yield when feed intake depressed and under stress
Propionibacteria
and L. acidophilis
P-63
5345
1 x 109
1 x 108
Improve feed efficiency during adaption to higher CHO diet
Propionibacterium
Freudenrechii and L.
acidophilis (B2FFO4)
na 1 x 109
1 x 108
Improve feed efficiency
Propionibacterium
acidipropionic
DH42 1 x 109 Increased propionic acid
Propionibacterium
Freudenrechii plus lactobacilli
na na Improve weight gain in calves

Selected References

  • Hutjens, M.F. 2005. Feed additives in dairy nutrition, an industry and farm perspective. New England Nutrition Conf. Proc. p. 82-88.
  • Hutjens, M. F. 1991. Feed additives. Vet Clinics North Am.: Food Animal Practice. 7:2:525.
  • Krehbiel, C.R., S.R. Rust, G.Zhand, and S.E. Gilliand. 2003. Bacterial direct-fed microbials in ruminant diets: Performance response and mode of action. J. Anim Sci (E.Suppl.2):E120-E132.
  • Kung, L. Jr. 2001. Direct-fed microbials for dairy cows and enzymes for lactating dairy cows: New theories and applications. Penn State Dairy Cattle Workshop Proc. Pp. 86-102.
  • National Research Council. 2001. Nutrient Requirement of Dairy Cattle, 7th edition. National Academy Press. Washington, D.C. p. 192.
  • Yoon, I.K. and M.D. Stern. 1995. Influence of direct-fed microbials on rumenal microbial fermentation and performance of ruminants: A review. J. Animal Sci. 8:6:533

“Extension programs and policies are consistent with federal and state laws and regulations on nondiscrimination regarding race, sex, religion, age, color, creed, national or ethnic origin; physical, mental or sensory disability; marital status, sexual orientation, or status as a Vietnam-era or disabled veteran. Evidence of noncompliance may be reported through your local Extension office.”

 

Disclaimer

This fact sheet reflects the best available information on the topic as of the publication date. Date 5-27-2007

This Feed Management Education Project was funded by the USDA NRCS CIG program. Additional information can be found at Feed Management Publications.

Image:Feed mgt logo4.JPG This project is affiliated with the Livestock and Poultry Environmental Learning Center.

Image:usda,nrcs,feed_mgt_logo.JPG

Project Information

Detailed information about training and certification in Feed Management can be obtained from Joe Harrison, Project Leader, jhharrison@wsu.edu, or Becca White, Project Manager, rawhite@wsu.edu.

Author Information

Michael F. Hutjens
Department of Animal Sciences
University of Illinois, Urbana
hutjensm@uiuc.edu

Reviewer Information

Dave Casper – Agri-King, Inc.
Jim Drackley – University of Illinois

Partners

Logos2.JPG

 

Five Steps to the Development and Implementation of a Feed Management Plan

Printer friendly version

Introduction

This fact sheet has been developed to support the implementation of the Natural Resources Conservation Service Feed Management 592 Practice Standard. The Feed Management 592 Practice Standard was adopted by NRCS in 2003 as another tool to assist with addressing resource concerns on livestock and poultry operations. Feed management can assist with reducing the import of nutrients to the farm and reduce the excretion of nutrients in manure.

The Natural Resources Conservation Service has adopted a practice standard called Feed Management (592) and is defined as “managing the quantity of available nutrients fed to livestock and poultry for their intended purpose”. The national version of the practice standard can be found in a companion fact sheet entitled “An Introduction to Natural Resources Feed Management Practice Standard 592”. Please check in your own state for a state-specific version of the standard.

The national Feed Management Education team has developed a systematic 5-step development and implementation process for the Feed Management Practice Standard as shown in figures 1 and 2. The steps of the flow diagram were chosen to coincide with the sections of the Feed Management Practice Standard. The first step focuses on defining the purpose(s) for considering the Feed Management Standard on a particular farm, either to: 1) feed to minimize excess nutrients in manure while maintaining production, performance, and reproduction, or 2) feed to improve net farm income by feeding more efficiently.

Please check this link first if you are interested in organic or specialty dairy production

Why Consider Feed Management?

The first step focuses on defining the purpose(s) for considering the Feed Management Standard on a particular farm, either to: 1) feed to minimize excess nutrients in manure while maintaining production, performance, and reproduction, or 2) feed to improve net farm income by feeding more efficiently.

Key participants at step 1 would be the producer, the nutrient management planner, and NRCS staff.

Where Does the Practice Apply?

The second step of the flow diagram focuses on identifying the conditions where the practice applies and making an initial assessment of the opportunity for the full development of a Feed Management Plan. The conditions where the practice applies as noted the in 592 standard include:

  1. Whole farm imbalance
  2. Soil nutrient build-up
  3. Land base not large enough, or
  4. Seeking to enhance nutrient efficiencies.

After defining the condition(s) for use of the 592 standard, an opportunity checklist is then used make an initial assessment of developing a complete feed management plan. The opportunity checklist can be found in a companion fact sheet entitled “Use of the Opportunity Checklist in Feed Management Plan Development”. The Opportunity Checklist can be found in species specific versions for beef, dairy, poultry and swine.

Key participants at step 2 would be the producer, the nutrient management planner, and NRCS staff.

How Do We Reduce Manure Nutrients?

The third step of the flow diagram focuses on the question of “how to reduce nutrients on manure used on the farm”. This step will not be considered by all farms. Two major ways that a reduction in on-farm manure nutrients can be achieved is through feed ingredient and exporting manure off-farm. Making the decision to make a ration change vs. moving manure off-farm has major economic implications.

An electronic decision aid tool has been developed to assist with this decision. The tool is called FNMP$ and a description and set of instructions can be found in a companion fact sheet entitled “Feed Nutrient Management Planning Economics (FNMP$)…Connecting Feed Decisions with Crop Nutrient Management Plans”. This spreadsheet tool estimates the quantity of manure nitrogen, phosphorus, and solids excreted based upon user inputs of feed program and animal performance (based upon procedures contained within ASABE Standard D384.2). In addition, using procedures defined in USDA Natural Resources Conservation Service publication “Agricultural Waste Management Field Handbook”, an estimate of harvested and crop available nutrients are estimated. This information is then used to develop an estimate of:

  1. land requirements for agronomic utilization of the manure
  2. time requirements for land application
  3. costs associated with land application and potential nutrient value (N and P only) of manure.

Key participants at step 3 would be the producer, the nutrient management planner, and the nutritionist.

Develop the Feed Management Plan

The fourth step of the flow diagram focuses on the development of the feed management plan. The key tool to assist with the writing of the plan is the Feed Management Plan (FMP) Checklist. The FMP checklist can be found in a companion fact sheet entitled “Use of the Feed Management Plan Checklist in Feed Management Plan Development”. The Feed Management Plan Checklist can be found in species specific versions for beef, dairy, poultry and swine.

A national Feed Management Plan template has been developed and can be found in the companion fact sheet entitled “National Feed Management Plan Template”.

Key participants at step 4 would be the producer and the nutritionist.

Implement and Monitor the Plan

The fifth and final step of the flow diagram focuses on Feed Management Plan implementation and monitoring. This step focuses on implementing those practices that will help achieve the purpose(s) that were selected at step 1. In addition, review dates are established so that the FMP will be utilized as an active management tool.

It is important that the outcomes of the feed management plan as it relates to manure volume and nutrient composition are communicated to the nutrient management planner as this may affect cropping recommendations.

Key participants at step 5 would be the producer and the nutritionist.

Summary

Following the five steps to the development and implementation of a feed management plan, can provide the basis for thoroughly evaluating the merits of feed management in relation to nutrient management at the whole farm level. Clear and frequent communication with everyone managing nutrients on the farm will be a key factor to the success of the feed management plan.

“Extension programs and policies are consistent with federal and state laws and regulations on nondiscrimination regarding race, sex, religion, age, color, creed, national or ethnic origin; physical, mental or sensory disability; marital status, sexual orientation, or status as a Vietnam-era or disabled veteran. Evidence of noncompliance may be reported through your local Extension office.”

Feed Management Plan Implementation and Development Flow Charts

 

Disclaimer

This fact sheet reflects the best available information on the topic as of the publication date. Date 5-25-2007

This Feed Management Education Project was funded by the USDA NRCS CIG program. Additional information can be found at Feed Management Publications.

Image:Feed mgt logo4.JPG This project is affiliated with the Livestock and Poultry Environmental Learning Center.

Image:usda,nrcs,feed_mgt_logo.JPG

Project Information

Detailed information about training and certification in Feed Management can be obtained from Joe Harrison, Project Leader, jhharrison@wsu.edu, or Becca White, Project Manager, rawhite@wsu.edu.

Author Information

J. H. Harrison jhharrison@wsu.edu, and R. A. White, Washington State University
A Sutton and Todd Applegate, Purdue University
Galen Erickson and Rick Koelsch, University of Nebraska
R. Burns, Iowa State University

Partners

Logos2.JPG

 

Becoming A Certified Nutritionist to Develop a Feed Management Plan – Natural Resources Conservation Service (NRCS) Feed Management Practice Standard 592

Printer friendly version

Introduction

This factsheet has been developed to support the implementation of the Natural Resources Conservation Service Feed Management 592 Practice Standard. The Feed Management 592 Practice Standard was adopted in 2003 as another tool to assist with addressing resource concerns on livestock and poultry operations. Feed management can assist with reducing the import of nutrients to the farm and reduce the excretion of nutrients in manure.

During the early 2000s the USDA Natural Resources Conservation Service (NRCS) and the American Registry of Professional Animal Scientists (ARPAS) developed a memorandum of understanding “that provides an opportunity for qualified ARPAS members to become Technical Service Providers for NRCS programs in the category of feed management.” Put simply, this means that consulting nutritionists are the most appropriate advisers to develop and implement a Feed Management Plan (FMP).

Please check this link first if you are interested in organic or specialty dairy production

The NRCS Feed Management 592 Practice Standard

The NRCS Feed Management Practice Standard is defined as “managing the quantity of available nutrients fed to livestock and poultry for their intended purpose.” The purposes of the 592 standard are:

  • To supply the quantity of available nutrients required by livestock and poultry for maintenance, production, performance, and reproduction, while reducing the quantity of nutrients, especially nitrogen and phosphorus, excreted in manure by minimizing the overfeeding of these and other nutrients
  • To improve net farm income by feeding nutrients more efficiently.

The ultimate goal of utilizing the Feed Management Practice Standard 592 is to develop a farm-specific FMP.

Becoming a Certified Nutritionist to Develop a Feed Management Plan

There are two options for becoming certified to write an FMP, depending on whether one chooses to be an ARPAS member and following Option 1 or choosing Option 2, which does not require membership in ARPAS (Figure 1).

Figure 1

ARPAS Member Certification Process (Option 1)

Information about becoming certified can be accessed at ARPAS. The process under Option 1 for becoming certified with NRCS as a Technical Service Provider in the area of feed management is a multistep process that should start with attending a Feed Management Workshop to gain knowledge in the process of development and implementation of an FMP. Workshops for 2008 are scheduled for June 14 in Dubuque, Iowa, and Nov. 12 near Harrisburg, Penn.

A second step is to pass the feed management exam for the species of interest. The exam will be available in the summer of 2008 (Figure 2).

The third step is to have completed an FMP at two farms (Figure 3).

Figure 2

The fourth step is to complete a NRCS Technical Service Provider Application form with ARPAS. This form can be found at NRCS Technical Service Provider Program. ARPAS will keep a record of those who have completed the NRCS Technical Service Provider Application form with ARPAS (Figure 4).

Figure 3

Figure 4

The fifth step of the process is to complete a Technical Service Agreement with NRCS. The agreement form will need to be completed in the state in which the work is done. The TechReg Step by Step Guide can be found at TechReg(Figure 5).

Non-ARPAS Member Certification Process (Option 2)

For those who choose not to be members of ARPAS, the four steps are required to become certified to write an FMP (Figure 6). These include: showing proficiency in using techniques described in Feed Management 592 Practice Standard; providing two references from where the 592 practice standard has been used; acquiring 15 hours of CEUs in feed management-related subjects every three years; and demonstrating knowledge and understanding of the NRCS National Planning Procedures Handbook – Part 600.5, Comprehensive Nutrient Management Planning Technical Guidance.

Figure 5

Figure 6

Disclaimer

This factsheet reflects the best available information on the topic as of the publication date. Date 4-12-2007

This Feed Management Education Project was funded by the USDA NRCS CIG program. Additional information can be found at Feed Management Publications.

Image:Feed mgt logo4.JPG

This project is affiliated with the Livestock and Poultry Environmental Learning Center.

Image:usda,nrcs,feed_mgt_logo.JPG

Project Information

Detailed information about training and certification in feed management can be obtained from Joe Harrison, project leader, jhharrison@wsu.edu, or Becca White, project manager, rawhite@wsu.edu.

Author Information

J. H. Harrison, Washington State University, jhharrison@wsu.edu
R. A. White, Washington State University
A. Sutton and Todd Applegate, Purdue University
Galen Erickson, University of Nebraska
R. Burns, Iowa State University
Glenn Carpenter, Natural Resources Conservation Service

Partners

Logos2.JPG

Acknowledgments

This Feed Management Education Project was funded by the USDA NRCS CIG program. Additional information can be found at Feed Management Publications.
This project is affiliated with the Livestock and Poultry Environmental Learning Center.

usda,nrcs,feed_mgt_logo.JPG

“Extension programs and policies are consistent with federal and state laws and regulations on nondiscrimination regarding race, sex, religion, age, color, creed, national or ethnic origin; physical, mental or sensory disability; marital status, sexual orientation, or status as a Vietnam-era or disabled veteran. Evidence of noncompliance may be reported through your local Extension office.”

Figures/images CC 2.5 Joe Harrison

Use of the Dairy Opportunity Checklist in Feed Management Plan Development

Introduction

This fact sheet has been developed to support the implementation of the Natural Resources Conservation Service Feed Management 592 Practice Standard. The Feed Management 592 Practice Standard was adopted by NRCS in 2003 as another tool to assist with addressing resource concerns on livestock and poultry operations. Feed management can assist with reducing the import of nutrients to the farm and reduce the excretion of nutrients in manure.

Please check this link first if you are interested in organic or specialty dairy production

The Natural Resources Conservation Service has adopted a practice standard called Feed Management (592) and is defined as “managing the quantity of available nutrients fed to livestock and poultry for their intended purpose”. The national version of the practice standard can be found in a companion fact sheet entitled “An Introduction to Natural Resources Feed Management Practice Standard 592”. Please check in your own state for a state-specific version of the standard.

The national Feed Management Education team has developed a systematic 5-step development and implementation process for the Feed Management Practice Standard. A complete description of the 5-steps can be found in a companion fact sheet entitled “Five Steps to the Development and Implementation of a Feed Management Plan”.

The second step of this process focuses on identifying the conditions where the practice applies and making an initial assessment of the opportunity for the full development of a Feed Management Plan. Key participants at step 2 would be the producer, the nutrient management planner, and NRCS staff.

The conditions where the practice applies as noted the in NRCS 592 standard include:

  1. Whole farm imbalance
  2. Soil nutrient build-up
  3. Land base not large enough, or
  4. Seeking to enhance nutrient efficiencies.

After defining the condition(s) for use of the 592 standard, an opportunity checklist (see pages 3-6) is then used make an initial assessment of developing a complete feed management plan.

The Opportunity Checklist is organized to first identify the resource concerns of:

  • Soil Condition – Animal Waste and other organics
  • Water Quality – Excessive Nutrients and Organics in Groundwater
  • Water Quality – Excessive Nutrients and Organics in Surface Water

If one or more of these conditions exist on an operation, then a FMP should be considered by completing the Opportunity Checklist.

The Opportunity Checklist is designed to determine the relative opportunity for feed management to impact Whole Farm Nutrient Management. The Opportunity Checklist is the first step in making a decision on whether to complete a FMP.

The checklist is meant to be used as an initial, quick, on-farm assessment tool. If the decision is made to complete a FMP, numerous additional feed management practices will be assessed in more detail with the use of the Feed management Plan Checklist.

The items shown in the Opportunity Checklist are the management practices which have the greatest opportunity for feed management to impact Whole Farm Nutrient Management. The ‘Benefit to the Environment’ column provides the possible impact the practice could have on whole farm nutrient management. It is meant to be informative and should not be answered for each farm.

If one or more of the Opportunity Checklist items are noted in the category of “moderate or lots of opportunity for improvement”, then the next evaluation step should be completed: Economic Evaluation (manure transport vs feed management change) or FMP Checklist.

Following on this fact sheet you will find a completed Opportunity Checklist as an example.

Dairy Opportunity Checklist:

Identify resource concerns and/ or conditions where practice applies and assess the Opportunities

Feeding management is one of six components of a Comprehensive Nutrient Management Plan (CNMP) as defined by the Natural Resource Conservation Service. Feeding management as part of a CNMP should be viewed as a “consideration” but not a “requirement” as some practices will not be economical on some dairies.

Resource concerns and the conditions where practice applies

Field specific resource concerns that may be impacted by feed management (but not limited too) are soil and water quality. For example, nutrients may build-up in the soil or leach into ground water due to manure application. Feed management practices with or without several other practices may reduce the volume and nutrient content of manure. If one or both of these resource concerns exist on an operation, then a Feed Management Plan (FMP) should be considered by completing the Opportunity Checklist.

Conditions where practice applies are whole farm imbalance, soil build-up of nutrients, land base not large enough, or operation seeking to enhance nutrient efficiencies. Feed management practices with or without several other practices may reduce the volume and nutrient content of manure and may be an effective approach to minimizing the import of nutrients to the farm. If one or more of these conditions exist on an operation, then a FMP should be considered by completing the Opportunity Checklist.

Opportunity Checklist

The Opportunity Checklist is designed to determine the relative opportunity for feed management to impact Whole Farm Nutrient Management. The Opportunity Checklist is the first step in making a decision on whether to complete a FMP. The checklist is meant to be used as an initial, quick, on-farm assessment tool. If the decision is made to complete a FMP, numerous additional feed management practices will be assessed in more detail.

The items shown in the Opportunity Checklist are the management practices which have the greatest opportunity for feed management to impact Whole Farm Nutrient Management. The ‘Benefit to the Environment’ column provides the possible impact the practice could have on whole farm nutrient management. It is meant to be informative and should not be answered for each farm. If one or more of the Opportunity Checklist items are noted in the category of “moderate or lots of opportunity for improvement”, then the next evaluation step should be completed: Economic Evaluation (manure transport vs feed management change) or FMP Checklist.

Dairy Information
Dairy Name
Date Completed
Producer Signature
Adviser Signature
Identify resource concern(s) and/ or the condition(s) where practice applies:
Resource Concern(s)
Soil Condition: Contaminants – Animal Waste and Other Organics

  • Nutrient levels from applied animal waste and other organics restrict desired use of the land.
Water Quality: Excessive Nutrients and Organics in Groundwater

  • Pollution from natural or human induced nutrients such as N, P, and organics (including animal and other wastes) degrades groundwater quality.
Water Quality: Excessive Nutrients and Organics in Surface Water

  • Pollution from natural or human induced nutrients such as N, P, and organics (including animal and other wastes) degrades surface water quality.
Conditions Where Practice Applies
Whole Farm Imbalance: Confined Dairy operations with a whole farm nutrient imbalance, with more nutrients imported to the farm than are exported and/or utilized by cropping programs.
Soil nutrient build-up: Confined Dairy operations that have a significant build up of nutrients in the soil due to land application of manure.
Land base not large enough: Confined Dairy operations that land apply manure and do not have a land base large enough to allow nutrients to be applied at rates recommended by soil test and utilized by crops in the rotation.
Dairy operations seeking to enhance nutrient efficiencies

Determine the Feed Management opportunities for addressing Resource Concerns:

On the following pages is a list of feeding management practices that can affect nutrient balance. Please read through each feeding management consideration and record your answer. If one or more of the Opportunity Checklist items are noted in the category of “moderate or lots of opportunity for improvement”, then the next evaluation step should be completed; economic evaluation or FMP Checklist.

Dairy Opportunity Checklist

Click here to view the Dairy Opportunity Checklist, example of the Dairy Information worksheet and an example Dairy Opportunity Checklist (PDF).

“Extension programs and policies are consistent with federal and state laws and regulations on nondiscrimination regarding race, sex, religion, age, color, creed, national or ethnic origin; physical, mental or sensory disability; marital status, sexual orientation, or status as a Vietnam-era or disabled veteran. Evidence of noncompliance may be reported through your local Extension office.”

Disclaimer

This fact sheet reflects the best available information on the topic as of the publication date. Date 5-25-2007

This Feed Management Education Project was funded by the USDA NRCS CIG program. Additional information can be found at Feed Management Publications.

Image:Feed mgt logo4.JPG

This project is affiliated with the LPELC.

Image:usda,nrcs,feed_mgt_logo.JPG

Project Information

Detailed information about training and certification in Feed Management can be obtained from Joe Harrison, Project Leader, jhharrison@wsu.edu, or Becca White, Project Manager, rawhite@wsu.edu.

Author Information

J. H. Harrison jhharrison@wsu.edu, and
R. A. White, Washington State University
A Sutton and Todd Applegate, Purdue University
Galen Erickson and Rick Koelsch, University of Nebraska
R. Burns, Iowa State University
D Wilks – Standard Nutrition

Partners

Image:Logos2.JPG

Use of the Dairy Feed Management Plan Checklist in Feed Management Plan Development

Introduction

This fact sheet has been developed to support the implementation of the Natural Resources Conservation Service Feed Management 592 Practice Standard. The Feed Management 592 Practice Standard was adopted by NRCS in 2003 as another tool to assist with addressing resource concerns on livestock and poultry operations. Feed management can assist with reducing the import of nutrients to the farm and reduce the excretion of nutrients in manure.

The Natural Resources Conservation Service has adopted a practice standard called Feed Management (592) and is defined as “managing the quantity of available nutrients fed to livestock and poultry for their intended purpose”. The national version of the practice standard can be found in a companion fact sheet entitled An Introduction to Natural Resources Conservation Service (NRCS) Feed Management Practice Standard 592. Please check in your own state for a state-specific version of the standard.

The national Feed Management Education team has developed a systematic 5-step development and implementation process for the Feed Management Practice Standard. A complete description of the 5-steps can be found in a companion fact sheet entitled Five Steps to the Development and Implementation of a Feed Management Plan.

The fourth step of this systematic process focuses on the development of the Feed Management Plan. Key participants at step four are the producer and their nutritionist. The key tools to be used at step four are the Feed Management Plan (FMP) Checklistand the Feed Management Plan Template. This fact sheet will concentrate on using the checklist. The next fact sheet in this series A National Template for Preparing a Dairy Feed Management Plan will discuss the template.

Please check this link first if you are interested in organic or specialty dairy production

Using the Feed Management Plan Checklist

The FMP checklist is designed to assist dairy operators and their nutrient management advisor to determine feeding management factors that affect nutrient management. The checklist is meant to be used as an on-farm assessment tool. The factors contained in this assessment can be used as a guide to document and identify feeding management practices that will impact whole farm nutrient management.

The FMP checklist is designed to assist dairy operators and their nutrient management advisor to determine feeding management factors that affect nutrient management. The checklist is meant to be used as an on-farm assessment tool. The factors contained in this assessment can be used as a guide to document and identify feeding management practices that will impact whole farm nutrient management.

The FMP checklist is designed to systematically gather information that can be used to develop the feed management plan. The organization of the checklist is divided into six management categories of:

  • targeting nutrient requirements
  • ration balancing
  • ration management practices
  • production aids/enhancers
  • monitoring tools
  • forage management practices

To use this checklist, each practice should be discussed with the operator: Are they already implementing the practice? If Yes, indicate so and skip to the next question. If No, discuss whether or not the practice could be implemented and consider the economic implications. In many cases the economic implications will be a “best professional” judgment by the consulting nutritionist or producer.

It is important to address the question “Will it be considered in the future?” as this can provide guidance for reviewing and updating the FMP in the future.

The ‘Benefit to the Environment’ column provides the possible impact the practice could have on whole farm nutrient management. It is meant to be informative and should not be answered for each farm.

By following this link you will find a blank copy of the Feed Management Plan Checklist (PDF file). Additionally, a Completed Feed Management Plan Checklist(PDF file)is available as an example.

The next step in the process is to write the Feed Management Plan. A fact sheet on developing the FMP is available at A National Template for Preparing a Dairy Feed Management Plan.

Related Files

To follow the references in this article, it is recommended that you print these PDF files and refer to them at the appropriate places in the article.
Feed Management Plan Checklist
Example Feed Management Plan Checklist(Dairy).

Disclaimer

This fact sheet reflects the best available information on the topic as of the publication date. Date 5-25-2007

This Feed Management Education Project was funded by the USDA NRCS CIG program. Additional information can be found at Feed Management Publications.

Image:Feed mgt logo4.JPG

This project is affiliated with the Livestock and Poultry Environmental Learning Center.

Image:usda,nrcs,feed_mgt_logo.JPG

Project Information

Detailed information about training and certification in Feed Management can be obtained from Joe Harrison, Project Leader, jhharrison@wsu.edu, or Becca White, Project Manager, rawhite@wsu.edu.

Author Information

Joe Harrison jhharrison@wsu.edu, and Becca White, Lynn Johnson-VanWieringen, and Ron Kincaid, Washington State University. Mike Gamroth, Oregon State University Tamilee Nennich, Texas A&M University.

Partners

Image:Logos2.JPG

Acknowledgments

This Feed Management Education Project was funded by the USDA NRCS CIG program. Additional information can be found at Feed Management Publications.
This project is affiliated with the Livestock and Poultry Environmental Learning Center

usda,nrcs,feed_mgt_logo.JPG

 

“Extension programs and policies are consistent with federal and state laws and regulations on nondiscrimination regarding race, sex, religion, age, color, creed, national or ethnic origin; physical, mental or sensory disability; marital status, sexual orientation, or status as a Vietnam-era or disabled veteran. Evidence of noncompliance may be reported through your local Extension office.”

Whole Farm Nutrient Management – A Dairy Example

Introduction

This fact sheet has been developed to support the implementation of the Natural Resources Conservation Service Feed Management 592 Practice Standard. The Feed Management 592 Practice Standard was adopted by NRCS in 2003 as another tool to assist with addressing resource concerns on livestock and poultry operations. Feed management can assist with reducing the import of nutrients to the farm and reduce the excretion of nutrients in manure.

Please check this link first if you are interested in organic or specialty dairy production

Introduction to Whole Farm Nutrient Management

Whole farm nutrient management (WFNM) includes the consideration of import of nutrients to the farm, movement and transformation (including losses) of nutrients within the farm operation, and export of milk, meat, crops, or manure.

In order to understand WFNM, it is necessary to consider all sources of nutrients, their movement within the farm, and how they might move to the environment. On most dairies, feed represents the largest import of nutrients, with fertilizer as the second largest import of nutrients. Feed Management practices currently exist to reduce imports of nutrients (particularly nitrogen and phosphorus) or decrease their excretion. Many of these specific practices and management considerations will be outlined in two assessment tools (see fact sheets- Opportunity Checklist and Feed Management Plan Checklist) as part of the implementation process of the Feed Management 592 Practice Standard.

Nutrient Utilization by the Dairy Cow

Nitrogen (N) is used for milk production in the dairy cow with an efficiency of ~ 25 to 35%. The remaining 65 to 75% of nitrogen consumed by the dairy cow remains in the initial manure (feces and urine). However, N is lost to the atmosphere via volatilization.

Phosphorus utilization by species varies from approximately 20 to 50%. The 50 to 80% not utilized is excreted in manure. A dairy cow uses approximately 27% of dietary P for milk production and thus approximately 73% of dietary P is not exported as milk from the farm.

“A dairy cow uses approximately 27% of dietary P for milk production and thus approximately 73% of dietary P is not exported as milk from the farm.”

Whole Farm Nutrient Balance

The goal of whole farm nutrient management is to achieve “zero farm balance” through the adoption of a variety of management practices, including Feed Management (see Figure 1). The practices and the relative positive or negative balance (balance = anything that remains or is left over) will be unique to each farm.

It is important to acknowledge that due to biological processes, there will be losses to the environment even when all the best management practices are adopted. Therefore, “zero balance” is difficult to achieve while maintaining high crop productivity.

The concept of Whole Farm Nutrient Balance has been described in different ways progressing from simple to more complex approaches. First, consider various approaches using nitrogen as the nutrient of interest.

1st Approach -The first approach is to estimate Mass-Balance uses the concepts of import and export of managed resources (see figure 2) at the farm boundary. This approach measures only those nutrients that cross the boundary of the farm and does not directly track nutrients flows within the farm or nutrient losses from the farm. The difference between inputs and managed outputs can be used to calculate a positive or negative balance. This positive balance represents nutrients that will be lost to the environment by both air and water pathways as well as those nutrients that accumulate on the farm (e.g. increased soil nitrogen levels). The positive balance provides an estimate of environmental risk.

2nd Approach – The second approach takes into consideration the import-export of nutrients as well as losses due to volatilization of nitrogen from manure during collection, handling, storage, and application (see figure 3). This approach would include the Mass-Balance approach, plus estimates of volatile nitrogen losses. This approach is commonly used for development of Nutrient Management Plans (NMP) and Comprehensive Nutrient Management Plans (CNMP) in many states.

3rd Approach – The third approach takes into consideration the losses of volatile nitrogen as well as leached nitrogen (see figure 4). This approach is also common to NMPs and CNMPs when leaching index tools and soil nitrogen indices are utilized in NM planning.

In contrast to nitrogen, phosphorus (P) is not lost to the atmosphere and therefore, what is not exported from the farm remains within the farmstead or possibly lost due to transport. Thus, the 1st approach (mass-balance) and 3rd approach (mass-balance plus surface and leaching loss) are the approaches that are more common for P based nutrient management planning.

Checklist Tools

The “Opportunity Checklist and Feed Management Plan Checklist” summarize the common Feed Management practices that can be adopted to assist with reducing the import of nutrients to the farm in the form of feedstuffs or reduce the excretion of nutrients in manure (see Figure 4). The opportunity checklist includes Feed Management practices or concepts that usually have the greatest initial impact. These include but are not limited to:

  1. formulation of diets to meet animal requirements,
  2. grouping animals according to nutrient needs,
  3. determining dry matter routinely and adjusting rations accordingly, and
  4. analyzing diet ingredients routinely.

Additional Feed Management practices and strategies that can further assist with reducing the importation of nutrients to the farm are outlined in the Feed Management Plan Checklist.

Spreadsheet Based Whole Farm Nutrient Management Tools

Several spreadsheet based tools are available to estimate the nutrient balance at the whole farm level. The name of these tools and where a copy can be obtained are:

  1. Whole Farm Balance Nutrient Education Tool – Washington State University
  2. Whole Farm Nutrient Balance – University of Nebraska
  3. Cornell Whole Farm Nutrient Balance Assessment Program

Summary

Whole farm nutrient management should include the consideration of import of nutrients to the farm, movement and transformation (including losses) of nutrients within the farm operation, and export of milk, meat, crops, or manure.

Whole Farm Fig 1.jpg

 

Whole Farm Fig 2.jpg

 

Whole Farm Fig 3.jpg

 

Whole Farm Fig 4.jpg

 

“Extension programs and policies are consistent with federal and state laws and regulations on nondiscrimination regarding race, sex, religion, age, color, creed, national or ethnic origin; physical, mental or sensory disability; marital status, sexual orientation, or status as a Vietnam-era or disabled veteran. Evidence of noncompliance may be reported through your local Extension office.”

Disclaimer

This fact sheet reflects the best available information on the topic as of the publication date. Date 5-30-2007

This Feed Management Education Project was funded by the USDA NRCS CIG program. Additional information can be found at Feed Management Publications.

Image:Feed mgt logo4.JPG

This project is affiliated with the Livestock and Poultry Environmental Learning Center.

Image:usda,nrcs,feed_mgt_logo.JPG

Project Information

Detailed information about training and certification in Feed Management can be obtained from Joe Harrison, Project Leader, jhharrison@wsu.edu, or Becca White, Project Manager, rawhite@wsu.edu.

Author Information

Joe Harrison
Nutrient Management Specialist
WSU-Puyallup
jhharrison@wsu.edu
253-445-4638

Rebecca White
Feed Management Educator
rawhite@wsu.edu

Partners

Image:Logos2.JPG

Evaluating Corn Silage Quality for Dairy Cattle

Printer friendly version

Contents


Introduction

This fact sheet has been developed to support the implementation of the Natural Resources Conservation Service Feed Management 592 Practice Standard. The Feed Management 592 Practice Standard was adopted by NRCS in 2003 as another tool to assist with addressing resource concerns on livestock and poultry operations. Feed management can assist with reducing the import of nutrients to the farm and reduce the excretion of nutrients in manure.

The Natural Resources Conservation Service has adopted a practice standard called Feed Management (592) and is defined as “managing the quantity of available nutrients fed to livestock and poultry for their intended purpose”. The national version of the practice standard can be found in a companion fact sheet entitled “An Introduction to Natural Resources Feed Management Practice Standard 592”. Please check in your own state for a state-specific version of the standard.

An index of forage quality, milk per ton of forage DM (Undersander et al., 1993), was developed using an energy value of forage predicted from ADF content and DMI potential of forage predicted from NDF content as its basis. The milk per ton quality index was later modified for corn silage (Schwab et al., 2003) using an energy value derived from summative equations (Schwab et al., 2003; NRC, 2001) and DMI predicted from both NDF content (Mertens, 1987) and in vitro NDF digestibility (IVNDFD, % of NDF; Oba and Allen, 1999b) as its basis. This milk per ton quality index (MILK2000; Schwab et al., 2003) has become a focal point for corn silage hybrid-performance trials and hybrid-breeding programs in academia and the seed-corn industry (Lauer et al., 2005). An update, MILK2006, will be discussed herein.

Please check this link first if you are interested in organic or specialty dairy production

Model NEL-3x and DMI

We (Schwab et al., 2003) modified the NRC (2001) TDNmaintenance summative energy equation for corn silage to include starch and non-starch NF C components with a variable predicted starch digestibility coefficient, and a direct laboratory measure of the NDF digestibility coefficient rather
energy value was derived from TDNmaintenance using the NRC (1989) empirical equation in MILK2000 (Schwab et al., 2003). In MILK2006, the NEL-3x energy value is derived using an adaptation of the TDN-DE-ME-NE conversion equations provided in NRC (2001).

Neutral detergent fiber content and IVNDFD are used to predict DMI (Schwab et al., 2003) in both MILK2000 and MILK2006. However, a one %-unit change in IVNDFD (% of NDF) from lab-average IVNDFD changes DMI 0.26 lb. per day (Oba and Allen, 2005; Jung et al., 2004) in MILK2006 versus the 0.37 lb. per day value (Oba and Allen, 1999b) that was used in MILK20

In MILK2000, variation in IVNDFD impacts NEL intake through effects on both NEL-3x content and DMI (Schwab et al., 2003). However, Tine et al. (2001) and Oba and Allen (1999a) reported that at production levels of intake, IVNDFD has minimal impact on NEL-3x content but impacts NEL intake primarily through effects on DMI. In MILK2006, the IVNDFD value used for calculating NEL-3x is adjusted for differences in DMI predicted from IVNDFD using an equation adapted from Oba and Allen (1999a). Thus, IVNDFD impacts NEL intake and hence the milk per ton quality index mainly through its impact on predicted DMI in MILK2006.

Non-fiber Carbohydrates and Their Digestibility

Dairy cattle nutritionists have long used non-fiber carbohydrate (NFC) as a quasi-nutrient rather than starch specifically. However, NFC is a calculated value (100-NDF-CP+NDFCP-Fat-Ash; NRC, 2001) comprised of varying proportions of starch, sugar, soluble fiber, and organic acids, and is subject to errors associated with analyzing the five nutrients used to calculate NFC. Although the NRC 2001 summative energy equation was based on NFC, starch rather than NFC is being used in summative energy equations (Schwab et al., 2003) by many commercial feed testing laboratories especially for corn silage which they have long been analyzing for starch content and have developed NIRS calibrations for starch determination. However, determining digestion coefficients for starch to use in summative energy equations has been difficult. The NRC 2001 model uses an NFC true digestibility coefficient of 98% and arbitrary processing adjustment factors. The MILK2000 model uses a non-starch NFC (NFC minus starch) true digestibility coefficient of 98% (NRC, 2001) and varies the starch true digestibility coefficient from a minimum of 76% (Firkins et al., 2001) to a maximum of 98% (NRC, 2001) using whole-plant DM and kernel processing as regression equation variables to predict apparent total tract starch digestibility (Schwab et al., 2003). Both approaches though are limited in their ability for detecting potential variation in starch digestibility across a wide array of samples, and novel lab assays are needed.

Starch, supplied in Midwestern and Northeastern diets primarily from dry or high-moisture corn grain and whole-plant corn silage, is an important source of energy for dairy cattle. However, the digestibility of corn starch can be highly variable (Nocek and Tamminga, 1991; Orskov, 1986; Owens et al., 1986; Rooney and Pflugfelder, 1986; Theuer, 1986). Various factors, particle size (fine vs. coarse grind), grain processing (steam flaked vs. dry rolled), storage method (dry vs. high-moisture corn), moisture content of high-moisture corn, type of corn endosperm, and corn silage maturity at harvest, chop length, and kernel processing, influence starch digestibility in lactating dairy cows. Because both physical and chemical properties of starch influence starch digestion, assessment of starch digestibility in the laboratory has been challenging.

In an attempt to address variation in starch digestibility, NRC (2001) suggested empirical processing adjustment factors (PAF) to adjust NFC digestion coefficients for high-starch feeds. However, since no system to measure variation in PAF for feedstuffs is available the PAF’s are subjective book values with minimal practical utility. For corn silage, U.S. Dairy Forage Research Center workers developed a kernel processing score (KPS; Ferreira and Mertens, 2005; Mertens, 2005) to assess adequacy of kernel processing in corn silage. But, the relationship between KPS values and in vivo starch digestibility measurements is not well defined. Ruminal in-vitro or in-situ degradation, either alone or in combination with in vitro post-ruminal enzymatic digestion of the ruminal residues, have been explored by some groups (Sapienza, 2002). Some commercial laboratories are attempting to employ in situ or in vitro systems to evaluate starch digestibility, but to date methods are highly variable between laboratories. Regardless of the method it is doubtful that samples can be fine ground as fine grinding of samples may mask differences among samples (Doggett et al., 1998). Relationships between in situ/in vitro measurements and in vivo starch digestibility are often not well defined. We recently developed an enzymatic lab assay, Degree of Starch Access (DSA), which is sensitive to differences in particle size, moisture content, and vitreousness of corn-based feeds (Blasel et al., 2006).

The DSA assay was found to be quite sensitive (Blasel et al., 2006) to particle size (R2 = 0.99) and moderately sensitive to DM content (R2 = 0.76) and endosperm type (R2 = 0.59), which are three primary factors that influence starch digestibility in corn grain. However, The DSA assay is a laboratory starch recovery procedure that does not result in a direct estimate of starch digestibility and only reveals differences in starch recoveries. For example, the DSA procedure would recover 95 percent of the starch in finely ground corn but only 5 percent of the starch in whole shelled corn. Thus, the DSA values provide an index of the variation in degree of starch access among feeds. We (Shaver and Hoffman, 2006) reviewed eight trials in the scientific literature (Taylor and Allen, 2005a; Remond et al., 2004; Oba and Allen, 2003; Crocker et al., 1998; Knowlton et al., 1998; Yu et al., 1998; Joy et al., 1997; Knowlton et al., 1996) with lactating dairy cows that reported total tract starch digestibility and particle size, moisture content, and endosperm type of the corns tested. From these data, we estimated their DSA values and evaluated the relationship between DSA and their measures of total tract starch digestibility. The resultant regression equation is applied to starch recovery values generated from the DSA assay to provide an estimate of total tract starch digestibility (termed Starch DigestibilityDSA; Shaver and Hoffman, 2006) which can be used in summative energy equations (Schwab et al., 2003; NRC, 2001) directly to calculate energy values for corn-based feeds on a standardized basis.

More field and in vivo evaluations of these laboratory assays related to starch digestibility (KPS, DSA, and in situ/in vitro) are needed. Therefore, the MILK2006 model continues to use the regression approach of MILK2000 (Schwab et al., 2003) as the default method for determining starch digestibility. But, user-defined options are available within the MILK2006 spreadsheet for determining starch digestibility from available KPS, DSA, or in situ/in vitro data. For hybrid performance trials where an objective is to assess true hybrid differences for kernel endosperm properties, the harvest maturity, whole-plant DM content, and sample particle size should be kept as similar as possible since these factors all influence the starch digestibility determinations.

Fiber and Its Digestibility

The NRC (2001) summative energy equation is based on fiber digestibility calculated using lignin. Whole-plant lignin content was found to have a strong negative relationship with IVNDFD within comparisons of brown midrib (bm3) hybrids to isogenic counterparts (Oba and Allen, 1999b). However, stover NDF and lignin contents increase while NDFD decreases with progressive maturity, but whole-plant NDF and lignin contents are constant or decline as grain proportion increases (Russell et al., 1992; Hunt et al., 1989). This may partially explain why for 534 corn silage samples, NDFD calculated using lignin according to NRC (2001) accounted for only 14% (P < 0.001) of IVNDFD variation (Schwab and Shaver, unpublished). Michigan State workers (Oba and Allen, 2005; Allen and Oba, 1996; M. S. Allen, personal communication, 2003 Tri-State Nutr. Conf. Pre-Symp.) reported that lignin (% of NDF) explained only half or less of the variation for corn silage IVNDFD. These observations coupled with the NRC (2001) suggestion that IVNDFD measurements could be used directly in the NRC model led us to implement IVNDFD rather than lignin-calculated NDF digestibility in the corn silage milk per ton models (Schwab et al., 2003). Use of NDF and IVNDFD in the corn silage milk per ton models has been discussed above.

Several commercial testing laboratories offer wet chemistry IVNDFD measurements. NIRS calibrations for predicting IVNDFD on corn silage samples are available at some commercial forage testing laboratories. However, Lundberg et al. (2004) found poor prediction by NIRS of corn silage IVNDFD. It is hoped that NIRS calibration equations can be improved upon in the future. The NRC (2001) recommended a 48-h IVNDFD for use in the NRC (2001) model, and for that reason we used 48-h IVNDFD measurements in MILK2000 (Schwab et al., 2003). However, debate continues within the industry about the appropriateness of 48-h vs. 30-h IVNDFD measurements. Some argue that the 30-h incubation better reflects ruminal retention time in dairy cows (Oba and Allen, 1999a) and that most of the in vivo trials that have evaluated effects of varying IVNDFD on animal performance also performed 30-h IVNDFD measurements (Oba and Allen, 2005). Labs and their customers also like the faster sample turn around that is afforded by the 30-h incubation time point. For that reason, and also for improved lab operation efficiency, a 24-h incubation time point is being employed by some labs. However, some argue that the 48-h incubation time-point is less influenced by lag time and rate of digestion, and thus is more repeatable in the laboratory (Hoffman et al., 2003). Hoffman et al. (2003) provided data on the relationship between 30- and 48-h IVNDFD measurements that showed a strong positive relationship (r-square = 0.84). But, the lab average at a specific incubation time point and the relationship between incubation time points within a lab can be highly variable among labs making the development of a universal incubation time point adjustment equation difficult. The average lignin-calculated corn silage NDF digestibility in the NRC (2001) is 59%. This reference point is important for adjustment of IVNDFD values from different labs and varying incubation time points so that the resultant TDN and NEL values are comparable to NRC (2001) values.

User-defined flexibility is available within the MILK2006 spreadsheet for entry of 48-, 30-, or 24-h IVNDFD incubation time point measurements. But, the labs incubation time point and average results for corn silage at that time point must also be entered into the spreadsheet along with the sample data. The 48-h IVNDFD incubation time point continues to serve as the default in the milk per ton spreadsheets. The Wisconsin Corn Silage Hybrid Performance Trials (Lauer et al., 2005) will continue to use the 48-h IVNDFD incubation time point because NIRS calibrations for this time point have been developed from corn silage samples obtained in this evaluation program over several years by locations and Justen (2004) did not find the earlier incubation time points to provide any benefit over the 48-h time point for hybrid selection.

Model Comparisons

Values for TDNmaintenance, NEL-3x, and milk per ton calculated using MILK2006 and MILK2000 across a wide range of whole-plant corn IVNDFD values and extreme quality differences are presented in Tables 1 and 2, respectively. The TDNmaintenance differences between MILK2006 and MILK2000 are minimal. The NEL-3x and milk per ton values are lower and the range in these values is compressed for MILK2006 relative to MILK2000 according to the equation differences between the two models that were described above.

Analysis of correlations between corn silage NDF, IVNDFD, starch, and starch digestibility and milk per ton estimates from MILK 2006, 2000, 1995, and 1991 models (n = 3727 treatment means; Shaver and Lauer, 2006) is presented in Table 3. Results show that the MILK2000 model was revolutionary relative to the earlier models (milk per ton hybrid rank correlation between MILK2000 and MILK1991 was only 0.68), because of its recognition of IVNDFD as an important quality parameter while the earlier models were influenced mostly by whole-plant starch and grain contents. The MILK2006 model relative to MILK2000 appears to be more evolutionary reflecting the relatively minor fine-tuning of equations (milk per ton hybrid rank correlation between MILK2006 and MILK2000 was 0.95), but the spreadsheet will allow for more user-defined flexibility. Future developments in laboratory methods for determining starch digestibility may influence its relationship to milk per ton estimates relative to the other quality measures.

Ivan et al. (2005) evaluated “low-fiber” (26% starch, 49% NDF, 58% IVNDFD) versus “high-fiber” (22% starch, 53% NDF, 67% IVNDFD) corn silages in 30% NDF diets fed to lactating dairy cows. Reported per cow per day milk yields were converted to milk per ton of corn silage DM basis using their corn silage DMI data. Actual milk per ton was 168 lb. higher for high-fiber than low fiber corn silage. Model-predicted milk per ton estimates were 132 lb. and 297 lb. higher for high-fiber than low-fiber corn silage from MILK2006 and MILK2000 models, respectively. This suggests reasonable agreement with in vivo data for MILK2006 and better agreement with in vivo data for MILK2006 than MILK2000. Presented in Figure 1 is model-predicted milk per ton minus milk per ton calculated using in vivo data from 13 treatment comparisons in 10 JDS papers (Ballard et al., 2001; Ebling and Kung, 2004; Ivan et al., 2005; Neylon and Kung, 2003; Oba and Allen, 2000; Oba and Allen, 1999a; Qiu et al., 2003;Taylor and Allen, 2005b; Thomas et al., 2001; Weiss and Wyatt, 2002) for MILK2006 versus MILK2000. There was less model over-predictive bias for MILK2006 than MILK2000. The model-predicted milk per ton minus in vivo-calculated milk per ton difference exceeded 100 lb. (approximately 1 lb. per cow per day) for only 2 of 13 treatment comparisons with MILK2006 versus 8 of 13 treatment comparisons with MILK2000.

While these observations with MILK2006 are encouraging, more model validations relative to in vivo data are needed. The MILK2006 Excel Workbook can be downloaded at the University of Wisconsin’s Extension website.

Table 1. Impact of IVNDFD (average lab IVNDFD 58% of NDF) in whole-plant corn harvested at 35% DM content with kernel processing on TDN1x (%), NEL-3x (Mcal/lb.) and milk (lb.) per ton using MILK2006 or MILK2000 with nutrient composition adapted from NRC (2001) for “normal” corn silage (8.8% CP, 45% NDF, 27% starch, 4.3% ash, and 3.2% fat).
IVNDFD% MILK
2006
TDN1x
MILK
2006
NEL-3x
MILK
2006
Milk/ton
MILK
2000
TDN1x
MILK
2000
NEL-3x
MILK
2000
Milk/ton
46 65.3 0.66 2936 66.4 0.69 3074
50 67.0 0.67 3037 68.2 0.71 3244
54 68.8 0.68 3138 70.0 0.73 3413
58 70.5 0.69 3237 71.8 0.75 3579
62 72.3 0.70 3336 73.6 0.77 3743
66 74.0 0.72 3434 75.4 0.79 3905
70 75.8 0.73 3530 77.2 0.81 4065

Table 2. Impact of “low” (45% DM, unprocessed, 8.8% CP, 54% NDF, 46% IVNDFD, 20% starch, 4.3% ash, and 3.2% fat) versus “high” (30% DM, processed, 8.8% CP, 36% NDF, 70% IVNDFD, 34% starch, 4.3% ash, and 3.2% fat) quality extremes in whole-plant corn on TDN1x (%), NEL-3x (Mcal/lb.) and milk (lb.) per ton using MILK2006 or MILK2000.
Quality MILK
2006
TDN1x
MILK
2006
NEL-3x
MILK
2006
Milk/ton
MILK
2000
TDN1x
MILK
2000
NEL-3x
MILK
2000
Milk/ton
“Low” 56.2 0.55 2242 57.3 0.58 2418
“High” 76.3 0.74 3617 79.9 0.84 4256

Table 3. Analysis of correlations for selected corn silage nutrients and their digestibility coefficients with milk per ton estimates from MILK2006, 2000, 1995, and 1991 models (n = 3727 treatment means; Shaver and Lauer, 2006).
r-values MILK
2006
Milk/ton1
MILK
2000
Milk/ton2
MILK
1995
Milk/ton3
MILK
1991
Milk/ton4
NDF% -0.46 -0.40 -0.94 -0.99
Starch% 0.48 0.44 0.75 0.74
IVNDFD, % of NDF 0.49 0.70 0.16 -0.10
StarchD, % of Starch 0.30 0.21 -0.25 -0.27
1Calculated as per Schwab et al. (2003) except for modifications discussed herein.
2Calculated as per Schwab et al. (2003).
3Calculated as per Undersander et al. (1993) except for in vitro DM digestibility adjustment.
4Calculated as per Undersander et al. (1993) using ADF and NDF.

Corn Silage Fig 1.jpg


References

  • Allen, M., and M. Oba. 1996. Fiber digestibility of forages. Pages 151-171 in Proc. MN Nutr. Conf. Bloomington, MN.
  • Ballard, C. S., E. D. Thomas, D. S. Tsang, P. Mandebvu, C. J. Sniffen, M. I. Endres, and M. P. Carter. 2001. Effect of corn silage hybrid on dry matter yield, nutrient composition, in vitro digestion, intake by dairy heifers, and milk production by dairy cows. J. Dairy Sci. 84:442–452.
  • Blasel, H.M., P. C. Hoffman, and R. D. Shaver. 2006. Degree of starch access: An enzymatic method to determine starch degradation potential of corn grain and corn silage. J. Anim. Feed Sci. Technol. 128:96-107.
  • Crocker, L.M., E. J. DePeters, J. G. Fadel, H. Perez-Monti, S. J. Taylor, J. A. Wyckoff, and R. A. Zinn. 1998. Influence of processed corn grain in diets of dairy cows on digestion of nutrients and milk composition. J. Dairy Sci. 81: 2394-2407.
  • Doggett, C. G., Hunt, C. W., Andrae, J. G., Pritchard, G. T., Kezar, W., and J. H. Harrison. 1998. Effect of hybrid and processing on digestive characteristics of corn silage. J. Dairy Sci. 81(Suppl.1):196(Abstr.)
  • Ebling, T. L., and L. Kung, Jr. 2004. A comparison of processed conventional corn silage to unprocessed and processed brown midrib corn silage on intake, digestion, and milk production by dairy cows. J. Dairy Sci. 87:2519–2527.
  • Ferreira, G., and D. R. Mertens. 2005. Chemical and physical characteristics of corn silages and their effects on in vitro disappearance. J. Dairy Sci. 88:4414-4425.
  • Firkins, J. L., M. L. Eastridge, N. R. St-Pierre, and S. M. Noftsger. 2001. Effects of grain variability and processing on starch utilization by lactating dairy cattle. J. Anim. Sci. 79(E. Suppl.): E218-E238.
  • Hoffman, P. C., Lundberg, K. L., L. M. Bauman, and R. Shaver. 2003. In vitro NDF digestibility of forages: The 30 vs. 48 hour debate. Univ. of WI Extension Focus on Forage Series. Vol. 5, No. 16. http://www.uwex.edu/ces/crops/uwforage/30vs48-FOF.htm.
  • Hunt, C. W., W. Kezar, and R. Vinande. 1989. Yield, chemical composition and ruminal fermentability of corn whole plant, ear, and stover as affected by maturity. J. Prod. Agric. 2:357-361.
  • Ivan, S. K., R. J. Grant, D. Weakley, and J. Beck. 2005. Comparison of a Corn Silage Hybrid with High Cell-Wall Content and Digestibility with a Hybrid of Lower Cell-Wall Content on Performance of Holstein Cows. J. Dairy Sci. 2005 88:244-254.
  • Joy, M. T., E. J. DePeters, J. G. Fadel, and R. A. Zinn. 1997. Effects of corn processing on the site and extent of digestion in lactating cows. J. Dairy Sci. 80: 2087-2097.
  • Jung, H.G., M., Raeth-Knight, and J. G. Linn. 2004. Forage fiber digestibility: Measurement, variability, and impact. Pages 105-125 in Proc. 65th MN Nutr. Conf. Bloomington, MN.
  • Justen, B. A. L. 2004. Digestion kinetics and vitreousness in breeding maize (Zea Mays L.) for silage yield and nutritional quality. M. S. Thesis. Plant Breeding and Genetics. Univ. of Wisconsin – Madison.
  • Knowlton, K.F., M. S. Allen, and P. S. Erickson. 1996. Lasalocid and particle size of corn grain for dairy cows in early lactation. 1. Effect on performance, serum metabolites, and nutrient digestibility. J. Dairy Sci. 79: 557-564.
  • Knowlton, K. F., B. P. Glenn, and R. A. Erdman. 1998. Performance, ruminal fermentation, and site of starch digestion in early lactation cows fed corn grain harvested and processed differently. J. Dairy Sci. 81:1972-1984.
  • Lauer, J., K. Kohn, and P. Flannery. 2005. Wisconsin Corn Hybrid Performance Trials Grain and Silage. Univ. of WI Ext. Publ. A3653. http://corn.agronomy.wisc.edu/HT/2005/2005Text.aspx.
  • Lundberg, K. L., P. C. Hoffman, L. M. Bauman, and P. Berzaghi. 2004. Prediction of forage energy content by near infrared reflectance spectroscopy and summative equations. Prof. Anim. Sci. 20:262-269.
  • Mertens, D. R. 2005. Particle size, fragmentation index, and effective fiber: Tools for evaluating the physical attributes of corn silages. Pages 211-220 in Proc. Four-State Dairy Nutr. & Mgmt. Conf. MWPS-4SD18. Dubuque, IA.
  • Mertens, D. R. 1987. Predicting intake and digestibility using mathematical models of ruminal function. J. Anim. Sci. 64:1548-1558.
  • National Research Council. 2001. Nutrient Requirements of Dairy Cattle. 7th rev. ed. Natl. Acad. Sci., Washington, DC.
  • National Research Council. 1989. Nutrient Requirements of Dairy Cattle. 6th rev. ed. Natl. Acad, Sci., Washington, DC.
  • Neylon, J. M., and L. Kung, Jr. 2003. Effects of cutting height and maturity on the nutritive value of corn silage for lactating cows. J. Dairy Sci. 86:2163–2169.
  • Nocek, J. E., and S. Tamminga. 1991. Site of digestion of starch in the gastrointestinal tract of dairy cows and its effects on milk yield and composition. J. Dairy Sci. 74:3598-3629.
  • Oba, M. and M. Allen. 2005. In vitro digestibility of forages. Pages 81-91 in Proc. Tri-State Dairy Nutr. Conf. Ft. Wayne, IN.
  • Oba, M, and M. S. Allen. 2003. Effects of corn grain conservation method on ruminal digestion kinetics for lactating dairy cows at two dietary starch concentrations. J. Dairy Sci. 86:184-194.
  • Oba, M. and M. S. Allen. 2000. Effects of brown midrib 3 mutation in corn silage on productivity of dairy cows fed two concentrations of dietary neutral detergent fiber: 1. Feeding behavior and nutrient utilization. J. Dairy Sci. 83:1333-1341.
  • Oba, M. and M. S. Allen. 1999a. Effects of brown midrib 3 mutation in corn silage on dry matter intake and productivity of high yielding dairy cows. J. Dairy Sci. 82:135-142.
  • Oba, M. and M. S. Allen. 1999b. Evaluation of the importance of the digestibility of neutral detergent fiber from forage: effects on dry matter intake and milk yield of dairy cows. J. Dairy Sci. 82:589-596.
  • Orskov, E. R. 1986. Starch digestion and utilization in ruminants. J. Anim. Sci. 63:1624-1633.
  • Owens, F. N., R. A. Zinn, and Y. K. Kim. 1986. Limits to starch digestion in the ruminant small intestine. J. Anim. Sci. 63:1634-1648.
  • Qiu, X., M. L. Eastridge, and Z. Wang. 2003. Effects of corn silage hybrid and dietary concentration of forage NDF on digestibility and performance by dairy cows. J. Dairy Sci. 86:3667–3674.
  • Remond, D., Cabrer-Estrada, J. I., Chapion M., Chauveau B., Coudure R., Poncet C. 2004. Effect of corn particle size on site and extent of starch digestion in lactating dairy cows. J. Dairy Sci. 87:1389-1399.
  • Rooney, L. W., and R. L. Pflugfelder. 1986. Factors affecting starch digestibility with special emphasis on sorghum and corn. J. Anim. Sci. 63:1607-1623.
  • Russell, J. R., N. A. Irlbeck, A. R. Hallauer, and D. R. Buxton. 1992. Nutritive value and ensiling characteristics of maize herbage as influenced by agronomic factors. J. Anim. Feed Sci. Technol. 38:11-24.
  • Sapienza, D. 2002. Pioneer tripartite method: Linking nutrient content to availability. Pages 27-40 in Proc. 64th Cornell Nutr. Conf. East Syracuse, NY.
  • Schwab, E. C., R. D. Shaver. J. G. Lauer, and J. G. Coors. 2003. Estimating silage energy value and milk yield to rank corn hybrids. J. Anim. Feed Sci. Technol. 109:1-18.
  • Shaver, R. D., and P. C. Hoffman. 2006. Corn silage starch digestibility: What’s new? In Proc. NRAES Silage for Dairy Farms Conf. Camp Hill, PA.
  • Shaver, R. D., and J. G. Lauer. 2006. Review of Wisconsin corn silage milk per ton models. J. Dairy Sci. 89(Suppl. 1):282(Abstr.)
  • Taylor, C. C. and M. S. Allen. 2005a. Corn grain endosperm type and brown midrib 3 corn silage: Site of digestion and ruminal digestion kinetics in lactating cows. J. Dairy Sci. 2005 88: 1413-1424.
  • Taylor, C. C. and M. S. Allen. 2005b. Corn grain endosperm type and brown midrib 3 corn silage: Feeding Behavior and Milk Yield of Lactating Cows. J. Dairy Sci. 88: 1425-1433.
  • Theurer, C. B. 1986. Grain processing effects on starch utilization by ruminants. J. Anim. Sci. 63:1649-1662.
  • Thomas, E. D., P. Mandebvu, C. S. Ballard, C. J. Sniffen, M. P. Carter, and J. Beck. 2001. Comparison of corn silage hybrids for yield, nutrient composition, in vitro digestibility, and milk yield by dairy cows. J. Dairy Sci. 84:2217–2226.
  • Undersander, D.J., W.T. Howard, and R.D. Shaver. 1993. Milk per acre spreadsheet for combining yield and quality into a single term. J. Prod. Ag. 6:231 235.
  • Weiss, W. P., and D. J. Wyatt. 2002. Effects of feeding diets based on silage from corn hybrids that differed in concentration and in vitro digestibility of neutral detergent fiber to dairy cows. J. Dairy Sci. 85:3462–3469.
  • Yu, P., J. T. Huber, F.A.P. Santos, J. M. Simas, and C. B. Theurer. 1998. Effects of ground, steam-flaked, and steam-rolled corn grains on performance of lactating cows. J. Dairy Sci. 81: 777-783.

“Extension programs and policies are consistent with federal and state laws and regulations on nondiscrimination regarding race, sex, religion, age, color, creed, national or ethnic origin; physical, mental or sensory disability; marital status, sexual orientation, or status as a Vietnam-era or disabled veteran. Evidence of noncompliance may be reported through your local Extension office.”

Disclaimer

This fact sheet reflects the best available information on the topic as of the publication date. Date 5-25-2007

This Feed Management Education Project was funded by the USDA NRCS CIG program. Additional information can be found at Feed Management Publications.

Image:Feed mgt logo4.JPG
This project is affiliated with the Livestock and Poultry Environmental Learning Center.

Image:usda,nrcs,feed_mgt_logo.JPG

Project Information

Detailed information about training and certification in Feed Management can be obtained from Joe Harrison, Project Leader, jhharrison@wsu.edu, or Becca White, Project Manager, rawhite@wsu.edu.

Author Information

Randy Shaver
Professor and Extension Dairy Nutritionist
Department of Dairy Science
College of Agricultural and Life Sciences
University of Wisconsin – Madison
University of Wisconsin – Extension

Reviewer Information

Pat Hoffman – University of Wisconsin
Jim Barmore – Nutrition Consultant

Partners

Logos2.JPG